Mixon Vs. Swift Trade

[Jintsfan66]

Fellas,

I have a owner chasing Swift and has made several offers. The last one was Mixon for Swift, Mclaurin and 2021 2nd. I am on the fence about this as some of the calculators have differing results


Do i make this trade or stand? this team was in the playoffs last year, is Mixon or Swift the better future play?

Look forward to your opinions

My Team:
Arod, Ben, Jimmy G, Herbert, Tannyhill
Zeke, Henry, D. Evans, Mack, Hines, Singletary
Allen, Evans, Boyd, Sheppard, Tate, Aiyuk, C. Samuel
Howard, Thomas, Jarwin

[Gator Sens]

I like Mixon a lot more than Swift.

[dblj1199]

I like Mixon more, but I wouldn't add a 2nd along with TMc.

[HughHoney]

Too much for me. I’d hold.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

I’d hold Swift, McLaurin and the 2nd.. easily

[Jintsfan66]

thanks guys, interesting i am on another forum and they all told me no brainer take it..lol

[24FlavorsofFun]

All about perceived value.

McLaurin is a good candidate to increase value this year.

draft picks a year or more out have about 1/3 their value come draft time.

Swift is currently unknown.

Those people are probably taking proven Mixon over unknown Swift, McLaurin and the far out 2.

I would also hold. Too much for Mixon.

[FantasyFoosball]

Swift/McLaurin side for me. At the very least I’d drop the 2nd from your side. Or maybe start with dropping McLaurin and offer Swift and the second if he’s so high on Swift.

[Jintsfan66]

thanks guys, it just feels too much to me as well and i like Mixon

[punintended]

I wouldn’t trade my shares of Mixon for that...

I’d need a first on top but I’m very low on swift

[mild]

I'd do it for Swift + the 2nd, but there's no way I'm giving up Scary Terry.

There's a non-zero chance he's the best player in this deal.

[FantasyFreak]

Not a chance. Way too steep for me.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

I like Mixon more than Swift, but Mclaurin is way too big a peice to add in. I actually like Mclaurin over Swift.
I'd counter with Shepherd or Curtis Samuel in place of Mclaurin. That's worth it for the upgrade imo, but not likely to get accepted.