Kamara+ vs Ridley+

[saw061600]

This is the first owner to actually engage in discussion of a trade in the league of this new Superflex, heavy scoring IDP orphan team.
I usually hoard WRs but in this superflex you can start 4 max and must start 2 RB. Getting a shot at 2 starting RBs on a team with only 1 current starting RB seems worth it.

Owner suggested Kamara for 1.03 and Ridley.

Seems a bit steep. Considering a counter of
Give: Ridley and 1.03 (possibly 2.05)
Get: Kamara and 1.09 (possibly 2.09)

FWIW, Swift or Akers has landed at pick 9 in two previous drafts in similar but less heavy IDP scoring.
Start 1-2 QB, 2-4 RB, 2-4 WR, 1-3 TE
QB: Murray, Stafford, Bridgewater, Winston
RB: Jacobs, Penny, Mattison, Hines, Armstead, J Samuels, R Freeman
WR: Golladay, Godwin, Boyd, Chark, Diggs, Kirk, Ridley, D Hamilton
TE: Fant, Dissley, Burton, garbage
K: who cares
DL: Fowler, Lawson, Barnett, Hurst
LB: Shaq T, Beasley, Mosley, garbage
DB: Peppers, Fitzpatrick, Bates, D Randall

[Ruggenater]

Kamara for 1.03 + Ridley is pretty close. I don’t see any way the Kamara owner adds 1.09 to his side, but if you can pull that off, it’s a slam dunk for you.

[Z$$$]

Agree that if you can get it done that’s good for you. Doubt you get 1.09 back. Worth a shot to start there and counter with the 2nd if he rejects.

[Gator Sens]

Kamara really helps your build, but its steep.

[Mjvb5]

Easily like incredibly easily Kamara for me

[StripesOfKC]

Kamara's best days are behind him
Would easily take Ridley+1.03 over him

[saw061600]

So the response range from "it's steep" to "easily take Ridley+1.03 over him." Just the kind of huge range of values I expected which kind of justifies me asking for the 1.09 in return...especially in this league where Young may end up in the top 24 scoring.

Thanks to all that replied and thanks to any that do so later.

[saw061600]

Well this trade moved to
Give: Godwin 1.03
Get: Kamara 1.09

Pass with my response: Have Godwin and Kamara pretty close, not moving down for that player swap.

[grooner]

Well this trade moved to
Give: Godwin 1.03
Get: Kamara 1.09

Pass with my response: Have Godwin and Kamara pretty close, not moving down for that player swap.

Agreed, I would have Godwin > Kamara so I wouldn't do this one. Ridley + something like 1.09-1.12 is what i think would be fair value. Maybe Rildey + 2.05 + 2021 2nd for Kamara?

[saw061600]

Well this trade moved to
Give: Godwin 1.03
Get: Kamara 1.09

Pass with my response: Have Godwin and Kamara pretty close, not moving down for that player swap.

Agreed, I would have Godwin > Kamara so I wouldn't do this one. Ridley + something like 1.09-1.12 is what i think would be fair value. Maybe Rildey + 2.05 + 2021 2nd for Kamara?

He's set on the 1.03 "gonna need a shot at one of the RBs in this class" which kind of makes clear he's down on Kamara and looking to upgrade in the draft.

Not sure I'd to it even for the 1.09 now. Owner with picks 4, 6, 7, 8, 11 has NO starting RBs with only Duke and James White on roster that are currently even on a team (Freeman, Hyde, Shady only other backs on roster) so my money is on that owner grabbing/reaching for every RB he can.