Mack's Value

[jab3120]

Was offered 3.06 and a 2021 3rd for Marlon Mack, should I take that deal and take what I can get for him or hold?

[Goddard]

Not a big Mack fan, but I'd probably hold out for a 2nd.

[Needalife]

I take it. This class is deep and Mack’s value could quickly go to zero. I like the deal more if you are in SF and/or IDP.

[jab3120]

I think I may hold for now, it is a good offer though and has me thinking. Just wanted to gauge what others thought. Thanks

[smbkrypt24]

I would hold. I am trying to buy Mack, but can't seem to work out a deal. I would easily pay a 2nd, but I don't own any.

[Gator Sens]

Mack is worth a mid to late 2nd for me. He could move on after this season and start elsewhere.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I take it. This class is deep and Mack’s value could quickly go to zero. I like the deal more if you are in SF and/or IDP.

x2 There are a ton of RBs scheduled to hit free agency after next season, so the odds of Mack ever being a starter again are slim. It was a risk/reward holding Mack through the NFL Draft. He would've been worth a mid 1st had IND not taken any impact RBs, but it sadly didn't work out for Mack owners. I'd take the 3rds.

[Dirty Mike&the Boys]

Not a big Mack fan, but I'd probably hold out for a 2nd.

This ^

[jab3120]

Seems like everyone is all over the place with his value, some saying take it some saying don't. I think I may take the deal gets me another 3rd this year which there is a lot of talent that could slip and it gets me a 3rd next year. Least it's something, rather than nothing as always trades are like playing the stock market. I'll know in a couple months if I should've held or if I made the right move. Lets roll these dice baby lol, also not a SF or IDP league.

[Goddard]

Seems like everyone is all over the place with his value, some saying take it some saying don't. I think I may take the deal gets me another 3rd this year which there is a lot of talent that could slip and it gets me a 3rd next year. Least it's something, rather than nothing as always trades are like playing the stock market. I'll know in a couple months if I should've held or if I made the right move. Lets roll these dice baby lol, also not a SF or IDP league.

I just feel like you should be able to get a future 2nd from the Taylor owner. The 3rds are pretty worthless, so not sure it's worth moving him for that right now when you might be able to get more. Maybe not right now, but possibly during the season. If not, then you lost out on two 3rds...I'm sure you're not going to lose any sleep over that. And even then, you can probably still get at least one of those 3rds for him.

[mpitera17]

If you can, I'd hold - the 3's are nothing and if anything happens to JT or he gets traded/hits the FA next year... value gonna spike.

[FantasyFoosball]

I'd easily hold him over that. He's still young and talented. He's the clear handcuff to Taylor. Taylor goes down with an injury, and Mack is back to 20+ touches a game. Not to mention Mack will still get his touches even with Taylor being there.

Mack may not be worth a late first anymore, but he's certainly worth more than a couple of mid thirds...

[jab3120]

Alright, with more people commenting seems the consensus is to keep and wait till after the draft and try for a 2nd. Well I haven't made the deal yet so there is that. Guessing I'll hold for now, I just don't want to get nothing for him if that makes sense