Guice vs 1.09

[IR1]

10 team idp, usually start 1 rb but can start 2. Have been looking for some rb depth as I “only” have Kamara, Mixon and Chubb. I’ve been offered Guice for the 1.09. This league has heavy scoring for idp, so expect at least 3 idp to go before that pick, essentially making it 1.06. Won’t be completely surprised if guys like Akers or CEH are still available there. With that in mind, would you prefer 1.09 or Guice?

[srlarson]

1.09....don't think Guice will make it back.

[-THE DUDE-]

1.09

[FantasyFoosball]

I like Guice, but I’d hold the pick here. Do you have a 2nd that you could counter with?

[IR1]

I like Guice, but I’d hold the pick here. Do you have a 2nd that you could counter with?

Thanks. Sent a counter with the 2.03.

[Gator Sens]

I like Guice, but I’d hold the pick here. Do you have a 2nd that you could counter with?

Thanks. Sent a counter with the 2.03.

Better way to go even if it does not get accepted. Need to see that Guice can stay on the field.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I like Guice, but I’d hold the pick here. Do you have a 2nd that you could counter with?

Thanks. Sent a counter with the 2.03.

I think this is closer. I would not pay the 1.09 for Guice unless you're his doctor and know for a fact he'll stay healthy from the magical PEDs you've given him.

[abloom]

I wouldn't have sent the 2.03 in a 10 team idp league for him. I'd send a late 2nd.

[Edgy68]

With those three RBs, it really doesn’t appear you need to push for another. I’d wait until you’re otc if you want to use that pick to trade. You’ll probably be happier with the offer then.

[ESKAY]

I wouldn't have sent the 2.03 in a 10 team idp league for him. I'd send a late 2nd.

I agree with this. I bet he takes that 2.3.

[IR1]

I wouldn't have sent the 2.03 in a 10 team idp league for him. I'd send a late 2nd.

I agree with this. I bet he takes that 2.3.

He did, we’ll see if I regret this but I haven’t completely given up on Guice

[LMS123]

I agree with the rest, based on Guices' history ill take the pick. Such a shame, he could be so so good

[ESKAY]

I wouldn't have sent the 2.03 in a 10 team idp league for him. I'd send a late 2nd.

I agree with this. I bet he takes that 2.3.

He did, we’ll see if I regret this but I haven’t completely given up on Guice

Nothing wrong with getting your guy with the 2.3. I gave up Guice last year for Edelman because I thought I could win. And he got me 2 points in week 15! Now he is 30 something years old with no QB or future. I wish I had Guice back now.

[Buckhill Bombers]

I own Guice in several leagues. No way I'd move him for a 2nd round pick. Yes he's been snake bitten, but so was Fred Taylor early in his career. Guice looked ELITE with the few games he played last year. I saw just enough to know IF he can stay healthy, he can be an elite 3 down back. I'd rather have that lottery ticket than a 2nd round pick. Just my humble opinion.

[diamonddave]

i'm pulling for guice! but if i could get a lotto ticket RB at 1.9, i'd probably flip for it