Trade away CMC?

[Trident]

I was offered the following:
Give: CMC and AJ Brown
Receive: Kamara and Nuk

Other notable pieces from the offering team include:
D. Adams
Juju
1.02, 1.05, 1.07, 2.02

The trade analyzer says the value is on the Kamara/Nuk side, but my gut says to keep CMC. What are your thoughts on the offer?

[Gator Sens]

I would hold CMC outside of another piece/pick being added.

[MattDeezy]

Throw in 1.02 + 2.02 and then I’d consider it.

[Indy Blue]

I think its a fair trade since its asking you to downgrade at RB, but is giving you a pretty big upgrade at WR. Really, it depends on what you think of AJ Brown and the Titans offense. He was super efficient last year and is likely going to regress unless the Titans become more of a pass heavy offense, which I think is unlikely. However, if you think the Titans are going to pass the ball more, and Brown will grow his target share, I might be wanting another piece thrown in. Probably won't get more than the 2.02, but you could see if he's buying the AJ Brown hype and ask for the 1.07.

[IR1]

Pretty fair to me, but since he approached you, I'd want the 1.05 added

[FantasyFoosball]

CMC side for me.

[Mike from Canada]

I'd want more.

[FantasyFreak]

CMC side by quite a bit for me.

[blacklab1010]

No way, in ppr it looks like this
2019 stats provide this
Aj 217 + cmc 471 = 688

Hop 270 + kamara 250=520

That 168 pt difference is equivalent of the rb# 25 montgomery
Or the wr#37 slayton. Even getting one of these guys isnt enough for me because i cant start them. Cmc is a huge advantage player because he scores the equivalent of having an extra starter like the 2 I mentioned above. I would need a player like one of them and a top pick to make it worth losing that advantage and still not sure i would do it.

[krtbuckeye]

CMC and AJB for me

[mmass]

CMC side easy

[AresGodOWar]

I mean CMC is awesome but getting Hopkins and Kamara a top 3 RB and WR for CMC and AJBrown , I don't think I could pass this up , I would try to get a little more added though

[blacklab1010]

I mean CMC is awesome but getting Hopkins and Kamara a top 3 RB and WR for CMC and AJBrown , I don't think I could pass this up , I would try to get a little more added though

this is true but did you realize the difference in points between that top 3 rb(kamara) and CMC this last year was Todd Gurley!!!
you would have needed to add todd and kamara to equal CMC!!!pretty crazy.....and its not possible to start them both in place of 1 RB

[Golly Dagger]

CMC + AJB side for me.

[M-Dub]

CMC easily. Take out AJ Brown and it’s close.