Mack-Guise Poll

[The Showstopper]

For Team 2

[FantasyFoosball]

This is Mack and it’s not close. I like Guice too.

[Zacsby]

This is Mack and it’s not close. I like Guice too.

x2

[Gator Sens]

Mack easily at this point.

[pmart33]

Mack by a mile.

[roofy61]

Piling on. Mack

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Mack >= Guice

However, since you already have Barkley and Kamara as your starters, I'd gamble on the upside of Guice staying healthy.

[Diti51]

agree. mack. one of arguably best offensive lines and creative offensive coordinator. only question is QB which they may address with veteran. but better team in Indy versus dumpster fire of Daniel Snyder and his Washington football team. Snyder just can't get out of his own damn way to repetitively ruin the franchise.

Mack all day, and Guice with two knee surgeries, hope he returns again, but that's a gamble. depends on how risk averse you are in dynasty, but with your starting core RB assets, agree with previous post could swing for fences with Guice, but would do so with eyes wide open for how bad the franchise is run.

[EAGLES]

I’m going Mack. GUI easy injuries concern me and they resigned AP, again

[killer_of_giants]

I’m going Mack. GUI easy injuries concern me and they resigned AP, again

incorrect. he was on a two year deal signed last season. it's a good sign, if they did cut him, they'd most probably need to draft another RB, who could be a bigger threat. we've seen who'll get the ball when healthy.

[Packerland]

I’m going Mack. GUI easy injuries concern me and they resigned AP, again

incorrect. he was on a two year deal signed last season. it's a good sign, if they did cut him, they'd most probably need to draft another RB, who could be a bigger threat. we've seen who'll get the ball when healthy.

Exactly! They will be rolling with Guice as the starter. AP is only a name at this point and not really a factor to take carries from Guice.

[EAGLES]

I’m going Mack. GUI easy injuries concern me and they resigned AP, again

incorrect. he was on a two year deal signed last season. it's a good sign, if they did cut him, they'd most probably need to draft another RB, who could be a bigger threat. we've seen who'll get the ball when healthy.

Thought he was picked up again, my bad! Either way, his injuries scare me lol

[Golly Dagger]

I chose Guice for a couple of reasons despite him being the riskier player at this point:

I'll start by saying I like taking risks on talent, and I feel like Guice's potential is far greater than Mack's - and while Guice might be a very risky asset - I feel like Mack is on a par in terms of risk due to his own injury history combined with not having any draft capital to really keep him afloat if he were ever challenged for a job - i.e. - I think he's replaceable. I also think we've seen Mack's ceiling already which isn't that high.

That being said, I think Mack holds more value, and if you moved Guice for him, you could probably just flip Mack for more value.

[Goddard]

Can we show Guice some respect and spell his name right (sorry, I see it misspelled so frequently and it's a pretty easy one to spell). Right now, the value is clearly on the Mack side, but I still like Guice more long term.

[darewood11]

Guice for the upside dor bbn me
Dont forget there was a guy with similar talents and similar injury problems named dalvin cook and then he stayed healthy...not giving up on guice yet. Mack could be totally irrelevant if colts grab a big name rb in draft or free agency