Derrick Henry and 1.11 or Dalvin Cook?

[joeday]

In a non ppr league, what side do you want?

[The.Big.Spank]

Henry and the pick for me.

[pmart33]

Henry and the pick for me.

X2

[Gator Sens]

I would take Henry and the pick here.

[joeday]

looks like its a consensus?

[Slackalacker]

Cook easily for me. I’m very low on Henry and am not expecting him to produce like that again.

[Goddard]

First thought was Cook, but it wasn't a very confident thought lol. I think Cook is maybe the "safer" pick, but Henry and the 1.11 help more...especially in non-ppr.

[diamonddave]

close...i wouldn't trade henry and 1.11 for cook though

[pandabears]

First thought was Cook, but it wasn't a very confident thought lol. I think Cook is maybe the "safer" pick, but Henry and the 1.11 help more...especially in non-ppr.

Completely disagree with this. Cool injured every year. Henry much safer and I prefer him without the pick.

[Goddard]

First thought was Cook, but it wasn't a very confident thought lol. I think Cook is maybe the "safer" pick, but Henry and the 1.11 help more...especially in non-ppr.

Completely disagree with this. Cool injured every year. Henry much safer and I prefer him without the pick.

That's why I put the quotations around safer. I don't necessarily agree with it, but that's what it feels like when he's actually healthy. Henry still has his inconsistencies when he starts off the season slow and then goes on a tear. Which Henry will we see next year? I feel more comfortable in saying that Cook will continue producing like a stud as long as he's healthy.

[Big Al]

Henry and the 1.11

[greenbird]

Henry side for me

[bridger32]

Henry and the pick!