Montgomery or singletary

[CooperCrush]

Which one do you prefer more and what is the difference between the two. Would singletary and Ross for Montgomery make sense? Or just stick with singletary?

[makemeasandwich]

I’d take Monty > Singletary, Singletary doesn’t have the size to be a bell-cow.

[Gator Sens]

I would rather gamble on Montgomery.

[jwb32]

Montgomery. Ross is starting to interest me but wouldn’t bridge the gap.

[killer_of_giants]

Singletary doesn’t have the size to be a bell-cow.

while monty doesn't have the skill.

i wouldn't give singletary for montgomery.

[Goddard]

I prefer the one who'll get me more in a separate trade.

[makemeasandwich]

Singletary doesn’t have the size to be a bell-cow.

while monty doesn't have the skill.

i wouldn't give singletary for montgomery.

Don't be surprised when they add another RB to carry the workload with Singletary.

[FantasyFoosball]

Singletary > Montgomery

I'm not adding anything to Singletary to get Montgomery.

[Mjvb5]

Similar draft stock
One was wayy overdrafted from landing spot and is still valued from those original thought
One actually looked good, both catching and running

I don't see why I would give anything with singletary for monty, I'd be looking for a piece coming back my way

[CGW]

Singletary has a bit more uncertainty involved as many see the bills will add a power back and run RBBC. That said, singletary was part of an RBBC this year and did just fine. This is a tough one.

I'd lean singletary, but wouldn't fault someone if they went with the volume play.

[killer_of_giants]

Singletary doesn’t have the size to be a bell-cow.

while monty doesn't have the skill.

i wouldn't give singletary for montgomery.

Don't be surprised when they add another RB to carry the workload with Singletary.

i'm thinking jordan howard, or someone like him.
by the way, where did i say singletary will be a bell cow RB?

montgomery is bigger than singletary, so what? he's not as good as he is. moreover, the bears should really involve tarik cohen more (and by that i don't mean 3 or 4 inside runs), he can get in one play what montgomery gets in one game. no guarantee it will happen of course, especially if they don't fire nagy.
also, montgomery had a total of 11 targets in the second half of the season (7 catches). that doesn't scream 3-downs back to me.

[makemeasandwich]

Honestly I wouldn’t want either player, so I’d probably just stand still and see how they pan out.

[diamonddave]

i go singletary all day every day. don't have him but would love him. would need something added to monty if i were a singletary owner