Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

This is the place for team advice - should I make this trade, should I draft that player, etc.

Who you got?

Cook
11
69%
Mixon
5
31%
 
Total votes: 16

blemly
Pro Bowler
Pro Bowler
Posts: 1087
Joined: Fri Apr 19, 2019 9:09 am

Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby blemly » Tue Jan 21, 2020 12:25 pm

Help me settle this debate I’ve been having with a good friend. Start of the 2020 season, which player would you rather have, Dalvin Cook or Joe Mixon?

Also, if you prefer one over the other, what draft pick(s) would it take for you to consider them equal?
Team 1: 12-team SF 0.5 PPR:
QB: Dak, Russ, Stafford, Geno, Dalton
RB: Harris, Gibson, Chubb, Cohen
WR: DK, Ridley, Kirk, Chark, Woods, C Samuel, Shepard, Reagor
TE: Fant, Knox
Team 2: 14-team PPR SF TEP:
QB: Wilson, Burrow, Geno, Foles
RB: Mixon, Gibson, Hines, Cohen, Pollard
WR: DJM, Cooper, Sutton, Deebo, R. Moore, ARSB, Eskridge, Renfrow
TE: Gesicki, Njoku, Arnold
Team 3: 12-team PPR SF:
QB: Watson, Lawrence, Winston, Cam
RB: Harris, Ekeler, Dobbins
WR: Hill, AJB, Woods, Chark, Lockett
TE: Gesicki, OJH, Firkser
Team 4: 12-team SF TEP Devy
QB: Wilson, Geno, Ryan, Cousins
RB: Zeke, Chubb, Sanders, Pollard, Hines, Cohen, Henderson
WR: Cooper, Godwin, Sutton, JuJu, Samuel, Fuller, Shepard, Campbell
TE: Fant, Gesicki, Ertz, Freiermuth
Devy: Boutte, Young, Slovis, Harris
Team 5: 12-team PPR SF:
QB: Dak, Lance, Jones, Cam
RB: Swift, Sanders, Dobbins, Pollard
WR: Sutton, DJM, Golladay, Chase, Pittman, Kirk, Campbell, Mims, Wallace
TE: Herndon, Gesicki, Freiermuth

User avatar
BigBawseRoss
GOAT
GOAT
Posts: 11550
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2017 5:56 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby BigBawseRoss » Tue Jan 21, 2020 12:35 pm

cook by a late first or so
team 1
12 team, 1 pt for 4 rec, 0.1 per rush
1qb, 3 rb, 4 wr, te, k, 4 idp
Dak , Herbert
Achane, Breece Hall, KW3Kyren,Ford, Miller, Spiller, z evans, singletary
J Jefferson, Diggs, DK, D Smith Puka, C Watson, E Moore
Njoku , HH, Engram

2024 picks
1,3,4,5,5,6,7 (all late mostly)

team 2
12 team .5ppr
qb, 2 rb, 2 wr, te, flx,flx,
Fields, Dak
Ford,Mixon, Javonte, Mostert, Chubb, Spears
Hopkins, Evans, g Wilson Mingo, shaheed, Jamo
Kelce,McBride, Chig,


1,2,3,3,5

team 3
14 team sf, even scoring idp to offense (rb scores highly too)
Josh Allen, A Rich, Foles, Rudolph
Bijan, Charbs, Spears, Ebner
J Williams, G Wilson, C Watson, Flowers, J Addison, Tillman
Kincaid, Kolar, Ruckert, Fergeson

Kenny Clark, josh allen, jaelen phillips, felix a-u and a bunch of fluff and rookie fliers at idp

jwb32
Ring of Fame
Ring of Fame
Posts: 3827
Joined: Wed May 10, 2017 8:11 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby jwb32 » Tue Jan 21, 2020 12:36 pm

I see them as equal though community seems to value Cook slightly higher. I would guess an early 2nd is the most you could get out of the average Mixon owner.
TEAM 1: 12 team league. 1.0 PPR WR/TE 0.5 PPR RB
Start 1QB, 2RBs, 3WRs, 2Flex, 1TE, 1DST
QBs- Lamar, Wentz
RBs- Javonte,Sanders, Michel,Howard,JJackson,JWilson
WRs- DJM,McLaurin,Higgins,DeVonta Smith,Jeudy, OBJ,Bateman,Treadwell,Crowder
TEs- Fant, Muth,Irv Smith
1.07,1.11,3.09

TEAM 2: 12 team league. 0.1 ppc 0.5 ppr. TE 1 ppr
Start 1QB, 2RBs, 3WRs, 2Flex, 1TE,
QBs-Watson, Davis, Huntley
RBs- Javonte,Akers, ETN,Gore,Dallas
WRs- McClaurin,DJM,Godwin,Diontae,MarquiseBr, Mooney,Van Jefferson,Collins,Atwell
TEs- Hock, Kmet,Trautman,AlbertO
1.04, 2.04, 4.04

TEAM 3: 12 team league. 0.5 ppr, 0.5/fd
Start 1QB, 2RBs, 2WRs, 2Flex, 1TE,
QBs- Lamar,Stafford
RBs- JT, Fournette, DHarris,Chuba,Collins,Gaskin,DHarris,Penny,Murray, Snell
WRs- Chase, DJM, Allen, Bateman, Julio, ElijahM, Mims, Crowder
TEs- Waller, Morneau,Njoku
2022 1st, 2nd (2), 3rd (2)

User avatar
Gator Sens
GOAT
GOAT
Posts: 53938
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2018 11:17 am
Contact:

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby Gator Sens » Tue Jan 21, 2020 12:39 pm

I prefer Mixon due to his lack of competition. Minnesota likes to get Mattison involved a bit too much. Pretty much equal in terms of value for me though.

Mjvb5
Legend
Legend
Posts: 5445
Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 7:29 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby Mjvb5 » Tue Jan 21, 2020 1:19 pm

Cook for me by early 2nd. Know a lot of people that prefer Mixon by about the same so it’s owner preference imo

User avatar
Vcize
Ring of Fame
Ring of Fame
Posts: 3666
Joined: Tue May 03, 2016 4:30 pm

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby Vcize » Tue Jan 21, 2020 1:31 pm

I have both and I value Cook much higher. I get the optimism around Mixon but I'll take the guy that just was a top 2 FF RB in ppg over the guy that we hear is going to be every year but has yet to actually come close.
12 Team FFPC TE Premium
QB: Herbert, Brady
RB: Barkley, Mixon, Jav Williams, Pierce, Drake
WR: Jefferson, AJ Brown, Metcalf, Hopkins, Peoples-Jones
TE: Kittle, Goedert

grooner
Player of the Year
Player of the Year
Posts: 2173
Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2012 10:01 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby grooner » Tue Jan 21, 2020 1:35 pm

I would prefer Mixon personally, but Cook is worth more. If I had Cook I would trade him for Mixon+easily.

User avatar
Goddard
GOAT
GOAT
Posts: 27771
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2017 9:21 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby Goddard » Tue Jan 21, 2020 2:13 pm

Cook should have more current value, but I prefer Mixon slightly. I viewed them both very close coming out and liked both, but always preferred Mixon by a smidge.

blemly
Pro Bowler
Pro Bowler
Posts: 1087
Joined: Fri Apr 19, 2019 9:09 am

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby blemly » Tue Jan 21, 2020 2:34 pm

Thanks guys, this has been very helpful. As it turns out, we are both “right.” He has Cook and wants to trade him for my Mixon + 2.03. I prefer, and believe that he prefers, Mixon to Cook. That being said, Cook probably has a slightly higher value than Mixon.
Team 1: 12-team SF 0.5 PPR:
QB: Dak, Russ, Stafford, Geno, Dalton
RB: Harris, Gibson, Chubb, Cohen
WR: DK, Ridley, Kirk, Chark, Woods, C Samuel, Shepard, Reagor
TE: Fant, Knox
Team 2: 14-team PPR SF TEP:
QB: Wilson, Burrow, Geno, Foles
RB: Mixon, Gibson, Hines, Cohen, Pollard
WR: DJM, Cooper, Sutton, Deebo, R. Moore, ARSB, Eskridge, Renfrow
TE: Gesicki, Njoku, Arnold
Team 3: 12-team PPR SF:
QB: Watson, Lawrence, Winston, Cam
RB: Harris, Ekeler, Dobbins
WR: Hill, AJB, Woods, Chark, Lockett
TE: Gesicki, OJH, Firkser
Team 4: 12-team SF TEP Devy
QB: Wilson, Geno, Ryan, Cousins
RB: Zeke, Chubb, Sanders, Pollard, Hines, Cohen, Henderson
WR: Cooper, Godwin, Sutton, JuJu, Samuel, Fuller, Shepard, Campbell
TE: Fant, Gesicki, Ertz, Freiermuth
Devy: Boutte, Young, Slovis, Harris
Team 5: 12-team PPR SF:
QB: Dak, Lance, Jones, Cam
RB: Swift, Sanders, Dobbins, Pollard
WR: Sutton, DJM, Golladay, Chase, Pittman, Kirk, Campbell, Mims, Wallace
TE: Herndon, Gesicki, Freiermuth

User avatar
metalmat
Starter
Starter
Posts: 676
Joined: Sat Oct 07, 2017 12:44 pm

Re: Trade Question: Cook/Mixon

Postby metalmat » Tue Jan 21, 2020 4:47 pm

Cook is worth more but I like Mixon more long term. I like Cook but I just don't think he is nearly as complete a back as Mixon. I think the Bengals getting Joe Burrow is really going to help Mixon flourish next season into that elite conversation where I think Cook has already hit his ceiling.
14 Tm ppr (rebuilding)
QB Wentz, Carr, MacJ
RB Mixon, Ty'son, Gaskin, McKinnon, Coleman, David Johnson, Freeman, Darrel Williams, J.Patrick, Ahmed, Dobbins, Hasty
WR Hopkins, T.Patrick, E.Moore
TE Jarwin, Ertz, Knox, Tremble
Picks: 22 (1,1,1,2,2,3) 23 (1,1,1,2,2,3)

12 Tm .5 ppr
QB Stafford, Hurts, MacJ, KMond
RB Zeke, Fournette, White, Mostert, Coleman, Pollard, Dallas, Perine, B.Scott, Nwangwu, Hawkins
WR Amari, Tyreek, KA, Chark, Renfrow, Agholor, Patterson
TE Fant, Knox, Doyle, Allie-Cox

12 Tm SF, TE+, ppr
QB Ryan, Winston, Mills, Minshew, Tua
RB Gordon, Carson, Harris, Hunt, Duke, D'Ernest, Dillon
WR Jefferson, Boyd, Ruggs, Davis, Parker, Hamler, Robby, Miller, E.Moore, Rodgers, Tre'Quan
TE Hooper, Conklin, Jarwin, Doyle, JuwanJ

14 Tm ppr
QB Stafford, Bridgewater, Fields
RB Hines, Harris, R.Jones, Murray, Freeman, J,Kelley, Hasty
WR Tyreek, C.Ridley, J.Chase, Aiyuk, Hardman, Renfrow, Campbell, Eskridge, Tre'quan
TE Kittle, Freiermuth, Kroft


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Jrblaha, Platt22 and 24 guests