Which side?

[JamboMac]

Team 3 in Sig.

I have made a couple of moves the last few days for my team.

1.02+Tevin Coleman for DJ Moore+2.11/2.12

Then last night..

Diggs+Gallup+2.11/2.12 for Hopkins

Given my WR corp at the start of the season (by far my weakest point at the time), it is now looking a million times better.

I have now been offered Adams+4th for DJ Moore+3rd - just want to clarify that I LOVE Moore, one of my favourite players in the league. But I do worry about his QB situation if Cam doesn't come back. Adams is clearly a great receiver, but the age difference is big for me, and he has also only had 1 truly great season so far.

Should I push the button on it, or stay? I'm leaning towards keeping Moore, as it's PPR and he has been very consistent, even with poor QB play.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I have now been offered Adams+4th for DJ Moore+3rd

Adams for me in a heartbeat

[Gator Sens]

Adams side

[Big Al]

I like DJ Moore but that's enough for Adams.

[crip7300]

I'm probably going to be significantly outnumbered here, but I would stay with Moore. Moore is 4 years younger and this year produced almost the same ppg avg as Adams, with Kyle Allen at QB. The odds would say you will get more lifetime value and numbers out of Moore from this point forward than you will out of Adams, barring injury. Plus, in 3 years Adams will be hitting that 30 year age wall, where Moore will just be hitting his prime and still more than likely carry good trade value.

[BigBawseRoss]

adams by a ton. thats a blessing to redeem the 1.02 for much better value than dj moore

[BigBawseRoss]

I'm probably going to be significantly outnumbered here, but I would stay with Moore. Moore is 4 years younger and this year produced almost the same ppg avg as Adams, with Kyle Allen at QB. The odds would say you will get more lifetime value and numbers out of Moore from this point forward than you will out of Adams, barring injury. Plus, in 3 years Adams will be hitting that 30 year age wall, where Moore will just be hitting his prime and still more than likely carry good trade value.

the goal is to win the league. look at his team!

[squidvicious]

Adams. You have McCaffrey, Elliott and Hopkins. Have to be in win-now mode. Rodgers is still great. I prefer diversifying the roster too. Next year, if Carolina puts up a dud in a playoff week, you would really get your playoff chances torpedoed.

[crip7300]

I'm probably going to be significantly outnumbered here, but I would stay with Moore. Moore is 4 years younger and this year produced almost the same ppg avg as Adams, with Kyle Allen at QB. The odds would say you will get more lifetime value and numbers out of Moore from this point forward than you will out of Adams, barring injury. Plus, in 3 years Adams will be hitting that 30 year age wall, where Moore will just be hitting his prime and still more than likely carry good trade value.

the goal is to win the league. look at his team!

I get that and totally agree, but is, let's say 2 ppg on avg worth 4 less years of similar production? Why have a 4 year window with Adams, when you could have a 8 year window with Moore. I really don't think Adams is that much more talented and again this year they are less than 1 ppg apart on avg. Also if you don't win the championship in the next few years and your window does close cuz the rest of your team is aging, at least you can still get good trade value out of Moore to rebuild. Adams will more than likely be only worth a 2nd if still productive and could be worthless. Plus players seem to get injured more as they age and tend to significantly lose value due to it. Just doesn't make sense for a few more ppg for a couple of years, just doubt those few ppg make much of a difference in most games outcomes, but giving up a young asset like Moore could set your team's overall value back a few years. Again just my opinion.

[JamboMac]

I'm probably going to be significantly outnumbered here, but I would stay with Moore. Moore is 4 years younger and this year produced almost the same ppg avg as Adams, with Kyle Allen at QB. The odds would say you will get more lifetime value and numbers out of Moore from this point forward than you will out of Adams, barring injury. Plus, in 3 years Adams will be hitting that 30 year age wall, where Moore will just be hitting his prime and still more than likely carry good trade value.

the goal is to win the league. look at his team!

I get that and totally agree, but is, let's say 2 ppg on avg worth 4 less years of similar production? Why have a 4 year window with Adams, when you could have a 8 year window with Moore. I really don't think Adams is that much more talented and again this year they are less than 1 ppg apart on avg. Also if you don't win the championship in the next few years and your window does close cuz the rest of your team is aging, at least you can still get good trade value out of Moore to rebuild. Adams will more than likely be only worth a 2nd if still productive and could be worthless. Plus players seem to get injured more as they age and tend to significantly lose value due to it. Just doesn't make sense for a few more ppg for a couple of years, just doubt those few ppg make much of a difference in most games outcomes, but giving up a young asset like Moore could set your team's overall value back a few years. Again just my opinion.

This is exactly where I'm at. Moore has the chance to be great! Look at his numbers in year two! Better than Adams first 4 years. Add 20 ppg to the 3 he missed this year and he is still only 10 points ahead of DJ in my league. This is why I'm struggling with it.

He is absolutely worth the 1.02 that I paid. Exactly the type of player I would have HOPED to draft, as I would have gone for a WR.

I'm still not 100% convinced it's the right thing to do, as I don't see much difference between the two, other than the QB situation. I think I may hold until I know more about that.

[SHIZZLE]

tough call, Adams is older, but if your in win now mode - I would grab Adams. he's the only guy rogers loves to throw at. Your WR's will be on the older side, so its concerning, but you will me the best at that position for the next 3 years probably.

[JamboMac]

tough call, Adams is older, but if your in win now mode - I would grab Adams. he's the only guy rogers loves to throw at. Your WR's will be on the older side, so its concerning, but you will me the best at that position for the next 3 years probably.

Yeah, this is the other conundrum. My reasoning for keeping Moore would be in the hopes that by the time Allen and Hopkins are aging, he will be the next best thing! It's a gamble with the QB situation. But he has been great this year given the current issues there.

I really don't think there is a wrong choice with this one, which makes it a little bit more difficult.