Trade Guice?

[NFL123]

Been offered a 2020 early 2nd for Guice, which will be either pick 12 or 13. Should I take it?

I have Chubb, Mixon, Bell, K Johnson and D Williams as my other RB's.

Guice's injury history and the fact he is on a bad team is worrying, one more injury and his value could plummet. If I take the pick I would have 4 picks inside the top 13 for the 2020 draft, plus another 2nd soon after. I really think I should take it, but is Guice worth more than an early 2nd?

[PhillySpecial]

Did you draft Guice early in 2018 or did you acquire him in a trade? He was likely a top 3 pick and now swapping him for pick 12/13 is a pretty big value loss. I understand the injury concern (I own him) but he may be on a Dalvin Cook trajectory to start his career.

[Gator Sens]

I would hold Guice for that price. Hopefully he stays healthy and gets some games the rest of this year and heads into 2020 healthy.

[Snake]

I’d take that in a superflex league, no questions asked. Ask for a little better in normal PPR. Maybe add a 2020 3rd that you can try to flip for a 2021 2nd on the clock?

I traded Guice for AJ Brown last week on a rebuilding team. Their age is a week apart and I value them similarly, but Guice’s situation seems so much more precarious. Another injury or Haskins sucking while defenses stack the box and Guice’s value will drop 3-4 rounds.

Your RBs are pretty good. Can you get a safer player with similar value?

[Ginge11]

Can you hold for another week? Redskins playing Lions this week. Guice is one big game away from his value going way up in dynasty.