Thielen and Ingram for my future

[lukkyseven]

Team 1 in signature. Competing for my Division (which is the hardest one in the league). Could make a playoff push if I win the division.

Do you trade:

Alexander Mattison
Lamar Miller
Preston Williams
Will Dissly
My 1st, 2nd and 3rd

for

Ingram
Thielen
Delanie Walker (would probably change this to an IDP player).

I feel like it's too much. Would removing Mattison make it closer?

[Goddard]

You're not really giving up a ton of value there. Preston and Mattison are nice pieces, but not really close for Thielen. A late 1st in a 16 team league isn't the same as a 1st in a 12 team league either. You can try to take out Mattison, but if the other owner doesn't go for it, I'd still make the trade.

[Gator Sens]

Good trade for your playoff push. You are not giving a whole lot up here outside of potential for known commodities.

[lukkyseven]

I feel like this is bad value for some reason. Let me put my thought's out into picks

Thielen - late 1st and 2nd
Ingram - late 1st and late 3rd
Fuller (IDP) - late 3rd
Total - 2x late 1sts, late 2nd, 2x late 3rds

for:

Actual late 1st, 2nd and 3rd
Mattison early 2nd
Williams early 2nd
Miller late 2nd
Dissly early 2nd
Total: Late 1st, 5x 2nds and a 3rd

[abloom]

I think you're getting very old and I can see this not planning out for you. Ingram's value has been boosted by two great games and theilin is dealing with a hammy issue. I know they said he'll be back soon, but hamstrings have a way of always being problematic