Melvin Gordon or Cooper Kupp

[Matt1975]

Who would you rather have if you had 1 pick and it was between those 2? PPR league

[Dibbles]

Tough one for me, I'd prob lean Kupp for the "better to build on WR's than RB's" rule . . . plus age difference and MGIII uncertainty for landing spot next year.

[Gator Sens]

Kupp. Looks the part of a legit top 10 -15 WR. Still young. Gordon is a toss up on where he will land.

[Goddard]

I probably would have said Gordon prior to the season, but has to be Kupp now.

[BradysBunch]

Kupp and not close for me.

[Jak]

From a Gordon guy - Kupp.

[Matt1975]

Who would you rather have if you had 1 pick and it was between those 2? PPR league

Update

I was offered Melvin Gordon and Alshon Jeffrey

For

Kupp and Chris Herndon

I really like Kupp and agree with all the responses on his value

[Matt1975]

Anyone have thoughts on this trade? I am torn

[lukkynumber13]

I like Alshon over Herndon, so if i am contending this year, I like the Gordon+ side.

Really close tho.

[Matt1975]

Thanks

[hoos89]

Who would you rather have if you had 1 pick and it was between those 2? PPR league

Update

I was offered Melvin Gordon and Alshon Jeffrey

For

Kupp and Chris Herndon

I really like Kupp and agree with all the responses on his value

Kupp side

[perkinsrooster]

Who would you rather have if you had 1 pick and it was between those 2? PPR league

Update

I was offered Melvin Gordon and Alshon Jeffrey

For

Kupp and Chris Herndon

I really like Kupp and agree with all the responses on his value

Kupp side for me because I'm not huge on Jeffrey. He seems fragile and not enough upside for make up for it. And lots of unknowns with Gordon.

[hoos89]

The gap between Alshon and Herndon is maybe a 3rd at this point? And I'd rather have Kupp than Gordon + 3rd.

[sugbear65]

Tough one for me, I'd prob lean Kupp for the "better to build on WR's than RB's" rule . . . plus age difference and MGIII uncertainty for landing spot next year.

I’d take Kupp as well, but keep in mind he’s also 26, only two months younger than Gordon, there is no real age difference.

[CubfanAA]

Tough one for me, I'd prob lean Kupp for the "better to build on WR's than RB's" rule . . . plus age difference and MGIII uncertainty for landing spot next year.

I’d take Kupp as well, but keep in mind he’s also 26, only two months younger than Gordon, there is no real age difference.

26 is much different for a WR than a RB. That is definitely a real age difference for fantasy value.