Page 1 of 1

CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 12:03 am
by gman6199
What is the value of McCaffery in a trade? I’ve been offered this trade and think it’s light:

Give
CMC
P Campbell
OJ Howard

Receive
OBJ
Miles Sanders
Royce Freeman

I think I can either get an additional WR (Deebo or Mclauren) or a top four 1st rd pick (2020). Which is a better route

10 Team Dynasty
QB- Darnold, Bissett, Cousins
RB-CMC, D Johnson, Michel, Lewis, Walton
WR-AJG, Edelman, Sanders, R Anderson, J Brown,
Washington, Tate, Stills, MVS, Campbell, White-Side, Williams (Buf)
TE-Olsen, OJ Howard, Herndon

Also TE Gesicki (MIA) is on the WW. Is he worth picking up????

I took this team over three years ago and I’ve been stuck in the middle of the pack. Need some advice.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 12:49 am
by FantasyFreak
Ten team league, you aren't going to win, IMO. I'd cash out on CMC, but you have to get a boat load. Not even sure I like OBJ, but honestly, you have to get the top 4 pick to even consider it. With your team, CMC is a sell, to get multiple players, but you need legit players like OBJ. I like Sanders as a PPR back down the road, but I think CMC is worth OBJ plus 1.04, plus Sanders right now. Scrap the rest of the deal. He's a league winner. I'd push for that in a ten team league. I would shop CMC around your league to cash out for the best deal to gain a tangible top 24 startup player plus other pieces. You need help with the team. I'd be moving DJ, Edelman, AJG and Emmanuel Sanders, as well as Olsen ASAP as well. I'd literally take a 4th for Olsen. He'll be announcing by the time you are ready to compete. In a ten team league, I feel you need to get a Godfather type deal for CMC, and move your other aging players and completely overhaul your team. I would send an offer to every team offering them CMC. Make it worth your while. Let it sit in their in box, saying, you hit accept, CMC is yours, but make sure you get what you want.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 1:14 am
by JoshuaGordon_9
I couldn't agree more with the guy above. If i'm selling CMC, I would look for a top WR you like (Hopkins, Thomas, Adams, Godwin even) plus additional pieces that will help in a rebuild. I'm not a huge fan of what we are seeing in Cleveland with OBJ either. He's had one good game, and has come out to say that he doesn't care if he's getting the ball or not, as long as the Browns are winning, he's happy. Well that's nice and all for Cleveland, but not for my fantasay team haha. Sell for maximun deal - definately shop him around, and don't just take the first deal you are offered.
For what its worth, last offseason, Barkley was sold in our league for Hopkins + Mack. There were other pieces involved, but that's basically what it boiled down to.
I would wait till AJG plays or gets traded to move him, but him, Edelman, DJ, Olsen are all trade bait. Try to sell to mid range teams that think they are a player or two away from contending, they may pay a higher price to feel that they are now a top team.
I'm not rushing to add Gesicki, but if you have the roster space, he may be worth a speculative add.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 1:42 am
by Samhain34
For this trade, I'd need OBJ, Sanders, McLaurin AND the first. The other team can keep Freeman.
Selling CMC is like selling Saquon. Collect the overpay or die.

After that I agree with this:
JoshuaGordon_9 wrote: Wed Oct 16, 2019 1:14 am I would wait till AJG plays or gets traded to move him, but him, Edelman, DJ, Olsen are all trade bait. Try to sell to mid range teams that think they are a player or two away from contending, they may pay a higher price to feel that they are now a top team.
I'm not rushing to add Gesicki, but if you have the roster space, he may be worth a speculative add.
Dump your older players and start hoarding young guys.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 4:45 am
by Gator Sens
I have no issue with selling CMC if it helps you long term, but that offer is not close. I would need a stud, a solid player and multiple picks. You only trade a guy like CMC with the season he is having once. Demand a ton or hold!

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 4:48 am
by FantasyFoosball
This is easily a hold CMC. The dude just turned 23 years old and is playing in a league of his own. I'm not selling him for any of that junk. Build around him.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 4:52 am
by jomaed
Run away for that offer quickly. Tell the guy its not even close and if he wants CMC to send something much better. As the deal stands now, Id need McLaurin and the 1st added on to think about it.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 8:08 am
by Goddard
Remove Campbell and Howard from your side and add a 1st on the other side. Probably an overpay at that point from the other owner, but that's what it should take.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 8:15 am
by WhatWouldDitkaDo
Gross. I'm not sure I'd sell McCaffrey alone for the other side. I certainly wouldn't add Campbell and Howard.

I'd counter with McCaffrey for Beckham + Sanders + the early 2020 1st.

Re: CMC trade question

Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2019 8:38 am
by Slackalacker
I wouldn’t even entertain the thought of selling cmc personally