Big Trade

[Tennisbuck]

Give

Mike Williams and Guice

Get

Mixon

[abloom]

i'll keep guice and williams here i guess.

i very well may regret it, but the potential of those two I think is better than Mixon.

[prinefan]

Mixon for me. He's proven and his drawbacks are the team around him, not his skillset. Won't always be like this. Not close IMO.

[Gator Sens]

Mixon for me. Stud RB on a bad bad team. I would gamble on that improving. I'm a huge Guice fan but...not sure it's going to happen.

[95dent]

I’m not high on Williams so it’s the Mixon side by a decent amount for me.

[Z$$$]

Mixon for me. He's proven and his drawbacks are the team around him, not his skillset. Won't always be like this. Not close IMO.

This for me as well

[Slackalacker]

I’m going with Mixon here pretty handily.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Not a huge fan of any of these three, but I guess I'd take Mixon due to perceived value. You might be able to flip him for more later in the season or in the offseason.

Mixon for me. He's proven and his drawbacks are the team around him, not his skillset. Won't always be like this. Not close IMO.

Maybe, but that's what Corey Davis owners have been saying for three years now.

[Goddard]

Mixon for me. He's proven and his drawbacks are the team around him, not his skillset. Won't always be like this. Not close IMO.

Maybe, but that's what Corey Davis owners have been saying for three years now.

Finding a good QB is usually harder to fix than the o-line though. Mixon at least showed last year that he can be a very good RB. Davis might still be bad even if he had a good QB because we haven't seen him with one yet.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Mixon for me. He's proven and his drawbacks are the team around him, not his skillset. Won't always be like this. Not close IMO.

Maybe, but that's what Corey Davis owners have been saying for three years now.

Finding a good QB is usually harder to fix than the o-line though. Mixon at least showed last year that he can be a very good RB. Davis might still be bad even if he had a good QB because we haven't seen him with one yet.

True, but I take into account team ownership / GM. I tend to stay away from investing in players on CIN, WAS, OAK prior to Gruden, etc.

[Goddard]

Maybe, but that's what Corey Davis owners have been saying for three years now.

Finding a good QB is usually harder to fix than the o-line though. Mixon at least showed last year that he can be a very good RB. Davis might still be bad even if he had a good QB because we haven't seen him with one yet.

True, but I take into account team ownership / GM. I tend to stay away from investing in players on CIN, WAS, OAK prior to Gruden, etc.

That's fair...but also would mean Guice is a player you'd want to stay away since he plays for Washington. So is getting Mike Williams worth losing a potential stud RB?

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Finding a good QB is usually harder to fix than the o-line though. Mixon at least showed last year that he can be a very good RB. Davis might still be bad even if he had a good QB because we haven't seen him with one yet.

True, but I take into account team ownership / GM. I tend to stay away from investing in players on CIN, WAS, OAK prior to Gruden, etc.

That's fair...but also would mean Guice is a player you'd want to stay away since he plays for Washington. So is getting Mike Williams worth losing a potential stud RB?

Huh? Not sure what you mean. I'm saying get Mixon and then flip him because the majority are still very high on him due to talent despite his awful situation.

[Goddard]

True, but I take into account team ownership / GM. I tend to stay away from investing in players on CIN, WAS, OAK prior to Gruden, etc.

That's fair...but also would mean Guice is a player you'd want to stay away since he plays for Washington. So is getting Mike Williams worth losing a potential stud RB?

Huh? Not sure what you mean. I'm saying get Mixon and then flip him because the majority are still very high on him due to talent despite his awful situation.

I didn't see the part about buying Mixon and flipping him. I just thought you meant you stay away from all players on the teams you listed and was confused because Guice is on one of those teams as well.