Dynasty League Football Forum

Ignoring rosters, which side in a 12 Team SF league 4 point pass TD.

AJ Green
Or
Jameis Winston

How far apart is the gap?

Lots going on in the Cinci WR depth chart, ongoing injury concerns (and new timeline), and skepticism of Jameis tenure in TB. Looking to assess the changing value perceptions.

I'd absolutely love to unload Jameis for AJ Green in the league I own him. Though I have very weak start able depth at WR there.

This really depends on what your evaluation on Jameis is. I no longer believe he'll ever become a fantasy difference maker. I see his upside as a fringe QB1-QB2 with inconsistent performances similar to Donovan McNabb back in the day, with the downside of completely busting out like Vince Young.

Green isn't without his risks, but if he didn't have them there's no way someone would trade him for Jameis at this point.

I dont think Winston is a good QB or will be a big fantasy producer at all, but in SF, I'm still holding him.

jameis, only bc it's superflex. i dont trust him but he'll get more points for a longer time than aj

Yuck, neither. But if I had to pick, Winston since you can probably sell him for a 1st still, or when he has a good game.

Ugh. AJG from my point of view as Winston might show some value but I think he's done in TB and will float as a back up for the next 4 years

Thanks for all the votes and feedback.

I own Jameis as my QB4 and nobody seems open to moving a 1st for him, either due to their team being too poor (risk of high pick) or just not liking him. My WR are Hopkins, Diggs, ARob, and DJ Moore, but with Trubisky and Cousins playing poorly, and Cam somewhat of a concern health-wise, my thought is that AJG may help be a reliable starter (he is when healthy), or even a comparable start to a SF QB in my championship question this year and next.

I was of the mindset I should be able to get more on top of Winston, but wanted to assess the concerns of others on his longetivty as a starter vs the short term benefits of Green (assuming he gets healthy).

I’ve been trying to unload Winston in the SF I own him in for a random 1st and no one is biting. If I weren’t in rebuild I’d take AJG and a late 2nd