Godwin trade

[Hankybro21]

Team 2. Was just offered the following

Give: Mixon
Get: Godwin

I am quite high on Godwin but Mixon seems too pricey. The only other trade piece I have for now would be Dalvin as I am in full rebuild. I planned to build a bit around Mixon. Owner also has Evans and DJ Moore, which I’ve tried to get earlier this offseason.

I’m more comfortable moving Dalvin than Mixon. Is Dalvin for Godwin straight up fairly even? Or does something need to be added. If they insist on Mixon, what needs to be added to the Godwin side? DJ Moore or a 1st?

[surgebird2]

I'd keep both your running backs. I like Godwin, but I'd still want a 1st added to Godwin for either one of those two.

[jcc6fd]

Cook is worth more than Godwin. In most cases probably by at least a first. Mixon is out of Godwins league in value. I’d ask for Evans straight up

[snaps06]

I'd keep both your running backs. I like Godwin, but I'd still want a 1st added to Godwin for either one of those two.

I agree.

To move Dalvin, it's take Godwin and a 2020 1st projected earlt.

To move Mixon, it'd take Godwin, early 2020 1st, plus another 1st or upside piece.

Godwin straight up for either one is laughable.

[snaps06]

Cook is worth more than Godwin. In most cases probably by at least a first. Mixon is out of Godwins league in value. I’d ask for Evans straight up

I like this suggestion.

[EAGLES]

Cook is worth more than Godwin. In most cases probably by at least a first. Mixon is out of Godwins league in value. I’d ask for Evans straight up

I like this suggestion.

No way you’re getting Evans for Godwin straight up. Godwin’s value isn’t that of Evans. Evans is right next to Mixon in startups

[TimeWillTell]

Cook is worth more than Godwin. In most cases probably by at least a first. Mixon is out of Godwins league in value. I’d ask for Evans straight up

I like this suggestion.

No way you’re getting Evans for Godwin straight up. Godwin’s value isn’t that of Evans. Evans is right next to Mixon in startups

Think he meant ask for Evans in return for his Mixon (original offer was give his Mixon for others Godwin)

[snaps06]

Cook is worth more than Godwin. In most cases probably by at least a first. Mixon is out of Godwins league in value. I’d ask for Evans straight up

I like this suggestion.

No way you’re getting Evans for Godwin straight up. Godwin’s value isn’t that of Evans. Evans is right next to Mixon in startups

I thought the suggestions was Mixon for Evans?

[chubnubbin]

Team 2. Was just offered the following

Give: Mixon
Get: Godwin

I am quite high on Godwin but Mixon seems too pricey. The only other trade piece I have for now would be Dalvin as I am in full rebuild. I planned to build a bit around Mixon. Owner also has Evans and DJ Moore, which I’ve tried to get earlier this offseason.

I’m more comfortable moving Dalvin than Mixon. Is Dalvin for Godwin straight up fairly even? Or does something need to be added. If they insist on Mixon, what needs to be added to the Godwin side? DJ Moore or a 1st?

I loveee Godwin - but i would hang on to mixon here.

[EAGLES]

I like this suggestion.

No way you’re getting Evans for Godwin straight up. Godwin’s value isn’t that of Evans. Evans is right next to Mixon in startups

Think he meant ask for Evans in return for his Mixon (original offer was give his Mixon for others Godwin)

Ahhhhh. Well, that makes complete sense lol completely misread that

[saw061600]

Keeping Mixon over Godwin

[Hankybro21]

Awesome thanks guys. I’m gonna guess we are too far apart already but I’ll push the Dalvin for godwin and 1st

[Gator Sens]

Cook for Godwin and a 1st is the only deal I would consider. Mixon is a hard pass.

[Goddard]

You're way too high on Godwin. Both RBs are worth more. Cook for Godwin and something decent in return would get me thinking.

[Hankybro21]

Ended up getting Godwin plus early 1st (top 3 or 4 most likely) for Cook