Sell Duke or hold?

[TTHTD]

Team in sig. I'm competing and a top 3 team in my league. There's interest in Duke + Crocket for a 2020 1st from a few guys, but does it make sense to sell my RB depth (and to my competition) with the Zeke holdout still ongoing? Plus I actually like Duke to have a good year. Should l sell or hold?

Also have an offer of Goff/Cam + Duke + Crockett for Watson.

[Pullo Vision]

I like the idea of selling Johnson, but a late 1st in a league where you must start 2 RBs isn't enough, for me. Using him to get the QB upgrade to Watson doesn't work for me, either.

Your sig team's RB depth is strong enough to survive an extended Zeke holdout. I wouldn't sell unless the value is strong.

[Mjvb5]

For a first he’s a sell for me

[RB6]

Take the first.

[Gator Sens]

Easy sell for a 1st in 2020. If he comes out and does not play well the first couple weeks, his value will go back to where it was last week.

[IR1]

I'd take the first, he'd have to do very well to have more value than that

[Goddard]

1st

[TTHTD]

So the general sentiment seems to be sell for a 1st even if it puts the teams ability to compete at risk. I kinda get it but it also kinda doesn't sit well with me...

Offered Watson + a late 2020 1st for Cam/Goff + Duke + Crockett + a 2020 2nd. That feels a little better to me since it improves my team. Hopefully he can work with that offer

[Favrezilla]

but a late 1st in a league where you must start 2 RBs isn't enough, for me.

This is DUKE Johnson. Folks...if you can get a 1st I’d be all over that as...you’ll be fine for a while with fournette and KJ.

I don’t that trade for Watson though...but if you like him that much more than cam or goff go for it, it’s not terrible

[Trevormortis]

Piling on. 1st

[Pullo Vision]

So the general sentiment seems to be sell for a 1st even if it puts the teams ability to compete at risk. I kinda get it but it also kinda doesn't sit well with me...

Offered Watson + a late 2020 1st for Cam/Goff + Duke + Crockett + a 2020 2nd. That feels a little better to me since it improves my team. Hopefully he can work with that offer

Perhaps people aren't in leagues where RB values aren't sky high. Where RB values aren't crazy, I'd easily prefer a 1st to Duke. However, in my wig league, people are always thirsty for RBs because of the starting requirement. Last year, I was able to get a 1st for P Barber. Given the OP's sig requires 2 RBs, figure the prices are car higher than the standard league. If history says otherwise, take the pick.

[chalorpas]

So the general sentiment seems to be sell for a 1st even if it puts the teams ability to compete at risk. I kinda get it but it also kinda doesn't sit well with me...

Offered Watson + a late 2020 1st for Cam/Goff + Duke + Crockett + a 2020 2nd. That feels a little better to me since it improves my team. Hopefully he can work with that offer

Perhaps people aren't in leagues where RB values aren't sky high. Where RB values aren't crazy, I'd easily prefer a 1st to Duke. However, in my wig league, people are always thirsty for RBs because of the starting requirement. Last year, I was able to get a 1st for P Barber. Given the OP's sig requires 2 RBs, figure the prices are car higher than the standard league. If history says otherwise, take the pick.

OP’s league is 12-team and starting 2 RBs is pretty standard? There’s a ton of RB depth in that format.

I wish I could sell my Duke for a 2020 1st. I’d be all over that.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

When are you ever going to start Johnson or Crockett given your depth at every position? I'd take the 2020 1st ASAP.

[EAGLES]

When are you ever going to start Johnson or Crockett given your depth at every position? I'd take the 2020 1st ASAP.

Completely agree. Take the 1st

[Pullo Vision]

So the general sentiment seems to be sell for a 1st even if it puts the teams ability to compete at risk. I kinda get it but it also kinda doesn't sit well with me...

Offered Watson + a late 2020 1st for Cam/Goff + Duke + Crockett + a 2020 2nd. That feels a little better to me since it improves my team. Hopefully he can work with that offer

Perhaps people aren't in leagues where RB values aren't sky high. Where RB values aren't crazy, I'd easily prefer a 1st to Duke. However, in my wig league, people are always thirsty for RBs because of the starting requirement. Last year, I was able to get a 1st for P Barber. Given the OP's sig requires 2 RBs, figure the prices are car higher than the standard league. If history says otherwise, take the pick.

OP’s league is 12-team and starting 2 RBs is pretty standard? There’s a ton of RB depth in that format.

I wish I could sell my Duke for a 2020 1st. I’d be all over that.

I've thought "standard" was start with 1 RB requirement. How many flexes varies. I was in one with the following requirements- 1Q, 0R, 23W, 1T, 1 R/W flex, 1R/W/T flex. Put crazy value on WRs and only the elite RBs truly mattered.