Mixon trade

[SWIMball]

Would Mack, Woods, and Ekeler be enough in a trade for Mixon and Josh Gordon, or should I be asking for more?

[thomasscheeks]

Mack, Woods and Ekeler probably won't be enough to trade for Mixon alone

[SWIMball]

Mack, Woods and Ekeler probably won't be enough to trade for Mixon alone

How far off would you say it is?

[Triton85]

I view that as about 50% in value off from where it needs to be. Unless the person is in a rebuild with a terrible team, even then I think you are at least a 2020 1st away from it being a reasonable offer

[Gator Sens]

Mack, Woods and Ekeler probably won't be enough to trade for Mixon alone

How far off would you say it is?

A 1st or a better piece then Ekeler but I personally would not move Mixon for any combo involving these pieces. Certain Mixon owners might however.

[thomasscheeks]

Mack, Woods and Ekeler probably won't be enough to trade for Mixon alone

How far off would you say it is?

The value is decent I suppose, but it's not all about value.

If I'm a Mixon owner, this offer wouldn't entice me the slightest bit. Mack has injury concerns and doesn't have the draft capital to stay relevant if his injuries continue. Woods is on a loaded offense and just now broke out, will he continue to play at that high level? Will he see as many targets with Kupp returning? And Ekeler is a decent pass catching PPR-flex type of player, not that enticing.

I would want some surefire players and/or some nice firsts for me to part with a great pass catching back like Mixon. Some so-so depth guys just aren't what people want when they're trading away legit studs

[Goddard]

What they said...not very close.

[Favrezilla]

Nowhere close

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Sorry to hijack this thread, but would someone please explain why Mixon is valued so much more than Mack? Both RBs have three-down potential, and even though Mixon is a bit more dynamic, Mack has a better offensive line and offense overall. I personally wouldn't pay Mack + Woods for Mixon.

[petebusey]

Sorry to hijack this thread, but would someone please explain why Mixon is valued so much more than Mack? Both RBs have three-down potential, and even though Mixon is a bit more dynamic, Mack has a better offensive line and offense overall. I personally wouldn't pay Mack + Woods for Mixon.

I’m guessing because of this:
Though Mixon and Mack may be a little closer in value in redraft leagues this year, dynasty format separates them greatly.
Barring injuries, Mixon is still going to be Mixon 2020 and beyond, a high end talent that will find him atop a a team’s depth chart, getting bellow touches, until he breaks down.
Mack, could be replaced by as the starter as early as next year by a more talented player. Or much easier find himself in a closer to even split. And that’s not even mentioning if/when he’s not running behind a very good line and plus game scripts.

[cptjonesb]

Mack, Woods and Ekeler probably won't be enough to trade for Mixon alone

X2

[thomasscheeks]

Sorry to hijack this thread, but would someone please explain why Mixon is valued so much more than Mack? Both RBs have three-down potential, and even though Mixon is a bit more dynamic, Mack has a better offensive line and offense overall. I personally wouldn't pay Mack + Woods for Mixon.

Draft capital and health. I wouldn't give up Mixon if Mack is the best piece in return

[Triton85]

Just a thought on mack (from a colts fan) - there is chatter about the Colts trying to trade for Zeke, there was chatter about them kicking the tires on Bell... Mack seems like a JAG to me that just happens to be in a good position for now

[Favrezilla]

why Mixon is valued so much more than Mack?

1. People drafted him highly
2. He led the afc in rushing?
3. I picked Mack of the waiver wire last year and sold him. (He available in two other leagues as well) I sold him for Henry + 2020 1st and am thrilled.

I’m not saying he won’t have a great year, or two. But he’s been inconsistent/injured Mixon has lived up to the hype and entering his 3rd season “should” be in for a potentially record breaking setup. Not sure anyone thinks Mack will be able to go for 2k+ total yds. ever.

[chubnubbin]

Would Mack, Woods, and Ekeler be enough in a trade for Mixon and Josh Gordon, or should I be asking for more?

Pretty far off IMO