Trader's Remorse: Asked to undo a trade with +

[johnnymozart]

Right around the NFL draft, I traded Mike Williams and Robby Anderson for 1.03 essentially to an owner who is a Bears fan.

Fast forward to the Monty hype and my drafting him at the rookie draft over the weekend-- I reached out unrelated to inquire about my own personal sickness, Josh Gordon, and if he was available. He replied with how badly he messed up and lost out on Monty and would essentially reverse the trade, but with Gordon added on his end. His team is very weak and will be an essential lock for 1.01-1.04 (bottom 4 all have equal shot at 1.01).

I think I have to do this, but I moved on roster wise and now would need to cut two additional people if I take on 3 WR or give him the two as a kindness cause his team is weak. The easiest candidate as #2 is Mike Davis. #3 I think is Marquise Goodwin-- the other guy just drafted Deebo too.

So would you give (in a start 2 RB Minimum, 14 teamer-- this needs to be pointed out for RB depth is hard to find!):
EDITED: Most calling for this not being enough. What about if the trade just added a 2020 early 2nd?
EDITED again-- changing a decent bit but bringing back a different package with his 2020 1st (top 4)

version2:
David Montgomery
Mike Davis
Marquise Goodwin
for
Mike Williams
Robby Anderson
Josh Gordon
Early 2020 2nd

Version 3:
David Montgomery
Mike Davis
Devin Funchess
Anthony Miller
For:
2020 early 1st
Deebo Samuel
Robby Anderson
Josh Gordon

[Mjvb5]

I would yes, but that’s because I’d rather have robby and mike than Monty to begin with

[sugbear65]

Nah, if he wants it make him pay. You don’t have to do any favors, plus he’s admittingly willing to pay the homer tax. His 1st next year sounds pretty nice, replace R. Anderson with that maybe. One less cut for you to make and the 1st gives you nice future ammo.

[Goddard]

I wouldn't. But I also have no interest in Gordon and would want something better added on top.

[killer_of_giants]

Nah, if he wants it make him pay. You don’t have to do any favors, plus he’s admittingly willing to pay the homer tax. His 1st next year sounds pretty nice, replace R. Anderson with that maybe. One less cut for you to make and the 1st gives you nice future ammo.

yep, mike williams, josh gordon and a first for montgomery and mike davis, see how it goes.

[johnnymozart]

Putting pressure on for his 2020 1st-- which he knows is probably equal to Monty in reality in itself, would be too much to pivot the trade from- he will balk. From the general perspective I'm lower on Williams than most, but higher on Robby.

What about if I added a seemingly simple (but may be 10 picks difference) swap of 2020 2nds on top? I don't want to scare away because I also want JGordon as my team mascot.

[Gator Sens]

I wouldn't. But I also have no interest in Gordon and would want something better added on top.

x2

[fab10]

Give me Monty

[johnnymozart]

If he added a 2020 2nd?

[4xship]

make him pay!!!!

[Mjvb5]

If he added a 2020 2nd?

I was with it before so you know how I feel

[hoos89]

I'd rather have Mike Williams + Robby Anderson than Monty, although since he's asking to unwind I'd obviously make him pay a premium to do so. The version 2 deal you have posted looks pretty attractive to me, although as others have said I'd definitely try to get a 2020 1st in there somehow.

[johnnymozart]

Sorry everyone, but it has evolved again into either version 2... or the version 3 he said he would accept. Let me know and send any links if you want me to help you out too!

[hoos89]

I'd definitely take version 3.

Early 1st > Montgomery
Deebo = Miller (personally I prefer Deebo, but I think market value has trended a bit the other way)
Gordon > Funchess + Davis
Robby Anderson = free late 2020 1st

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Montgomery = early 1st
Samuel > Miller

Anderson + Gordon for free is nice. I'd probably take version 3.