Trade Opinion: Cook/Corey Davis vs Mixon/Pettis

[Dr. Trades]

(For team 2 in sig)
I have been entertaining a swap of mixon for cook in a combo trade, since I have a share of mixon in both of my dynasty leagues. While I like mixon more because for multiple reasons, his seemingly lower injury risk is the obvious so I want something in return. Does the value of CD over Pettis make up for that or should I be expecting more? While multiple dynasty sites still have CD over Pettis, I’ve also seen multiple/majority of sites projecting Pettis over CD THIS year. This got me to thinking about CD’s current value and how he can be so much high in dynasty rankings. Should I pull the trigger in the two for two deal, or hold what I’ve got or ask for/expect more? (As you can see I have a pretty strong team and am in win now, but also young and built for future outside of my qbs)

Thx

[Mjvb5]

I don't have much of a difference between Pettis and CD
IMO I'd want a piece like Davis to trade Mixon for Cook

[Needalife]

I like Mixon over Cook too much here. Pettis is relatively even with Davis but plays in a more explosive offense. Gimme Mixon/Pettis here all day every day.

[BradysBunch]

I like Mixon over Cook too much here. Pettis is relatively even with Davis but plays in a more explosive offense. Gimme Mixon/Pettis here all day every day.

X2

[Gator Sens]

Mixon/Pettis side. Mixon is the prime piece on either side.

[Goddard]

Definitely the Mixon side.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Mixon + Pettis for me too, but I think it's closer than the poll results might suggest.

[Suhmdog]

Mixon side for me. I have cook and davis and I would trade the for mixon and Pettis in a heartbeat

[jcc6fd]

Pettis should not be viewed equally to CD but I’d still take Mixon

[Dr. Trades]

Thx for input y’all. The poll results so far are just a little surprising. I prefer mixon myself (been high on him since coming out of college), but with current projections for 2019 seeming to hype Cook through the roof, I did expect opinions on mixon/cook to be more evenly split (injury history aside). But from these comments, seems like gap from mixon to cook is larger than gap from Davis to Pettis, where I thought it’d be the other way around.

[FuzzySignificance]

i think it's real close, probably wanting a clearer upgrade than davis though (even though I like him quite a bit)

[pokerplayer1000]

Pettis should not be viewed equally to CD but I’d still take Mixon

This for me...I also think Cook has a ton of talent but the difference is Mixon has played 28/32 games in 2 years while cook has played 14/32.

[BigBawseRoss]

voted cook and davis i think davis ceiling is way higher than pettis and cook and mixon very equal. both players have concerns

[Dr. Trades]

Have views on this trade swayed in recent weeks with the passing of preseason week 1? I like Pettis a lot, but reports are not exactly glowing about Pettis lately. get feeling that there will be a lot of mouthes to feed in San Fran, whereas CD should be a pretty clear primary target. Not about to make any brash decisions based on one preseason game, but I still think it’s something of note to consider

[BigBawseRoss]

Have views on this trade swayed in recent weeks with the passing of preseason week 1? I like Pettis a lot, but reports are not exactly glowing about Pettis lately. get feeling that there will be a lot of mouthes to feed in San Fran, whereas CD should be a pretty clear primary target. Not about to make any brash decisions based on one preseason game, but I still think it’s something of note to consider

mine hasnt but im sure others have haha. pettis is a good bit down from CD for me personally and mixon vs cook is a toss up but i do prefer mixon. i think this is a fine trade but you could ask for something pretty decent to be added to cook and cd and say that you are concerned with cooks injury history and need something to close the gap and make it a done deal.