Cook++ for Kerryon++ Trade Poll

[lanemitchell96]

So I made this trade about a week back and I wanted to see what you guys thought of it. Superflex PPR, 1st team in sig (Apex Predators)

I feel like I won this trade, but I'm fairly new to dynasty and wanted to get the public opinion.

I RECEIVED:
Dalvin Cook
Anthony Miller
Parris Campbell
Tony Pollard
2020 2nd (from a very bad team)

I GAVE:
Kerryon Johnson
Kenyan Drake
Ronald Jones
Curtis Samuel

Basically my reasoning was that I definitely had enough depth to give up both Kerryon and Drake along with a couple depth pieces in Rojo and Samuel to upgrade my flex to Cook, and get a couple guys for my bench that I believe in a bit more than the ones I gave up. Thoughts?

[prinefan]

My preference is the Kerryon side. By a good bit.

[lanemitchell96]

My preference is the Kerryon side. By a good bit.

Are you higher on Kerryon than Cook straight up?

[FantasyFoosball]

Give me the Kerryon side. I think Cook is better than KJ, but I think you lost everywhere else. You lost a lot of RB depth. You basically traded KJ, Drake, and Rojo, for Cook. That's going to hurt your team.

Cook > KJ

Drake > Miller
Curtis Samuel > Parris Campbell
Rojo > 2020 2nd/Pollard

[ChefHerbie]

Give me the Kerryon side. I think Cook is better than KJ, but I think you lost everywhere else. You lost a lot of RB depth. You basically traded KJ, Drake, and Rojo, for Cook. That's going to hurt your team.

Cook > KJ

Drake > Miller
Curtis Samuel > Parris Campbell
Rojo > 2020 2nd/Pollard

This

[surgebird2]

I love Kerryon, but I voted for the Dalvin side. That said, it's really close. The way I see it

Cook >= Kerryon
Drake >= Miller
Samuel = Campbell
Pollard/2020 2nd > Rojo

I'm not sure why anyone is complaining about your depth. You never would have started any of those guys anyways, and clearly you have more faith in the guys you got. I say solid trade and it's pretty even.

[prinefan]

I do like Kerryon a little more straight up. Just watching their styles, I could see Dalvin getting hurt more ( I know Kerryon gets dinged too). I also love Samuel long term.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Miller = Drake
Jones = early 2020 2nd
Kerryon >= Campbell
Cook >>> Samuel

I feel like Samuel is insanely overvalued right now and would need Samuel + 1st to sell Campbell. These are all volatile players whose values can go up or down this year though, so the jury's out until January. Personally though I think you stole Cook. Nice trade.

[Gator Sens]

Kind of a coin flip or player preference here. I like the Kerryon side but it's very close for me. I would be pleased with either package.

[Titans95]

I love Kerryon but I lean toward Cook.

Cook>Kerryon
Parris>Samuel
Anthony Miller>=Drake
2020 2nd > Rojo