Evans++ for Allen++ (POLL)

[fraction]

This is the follow-up from these trade discussions: viewtopic.php?f=6&t=186718

Team 2 in Sig:

Give: Evans, Ertz, Henry, Pettis

Get: K. Allen, A. Jones, R. Woods, Njoku, 2020 1st

Does it even make sense?

[Gator Sens]

I would hold what you have but the 1st makes this pretty close.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Evans + Pettis = Allen + Woods
Ertz = Njoku + 2020 1st
Jones > Henry by a bit

It's close, but I'd accept that trade.

[pokerplayer1000]

I think the overall pieces make the value close-ish but it seems to me you downgrade from Evans to Keenan (small downgrade, but evans is also 2 full years younger), Huge downgrade from Ertz to Njoku, Henry and Jones are close to a lateral, and you slightly upgrade from pettis to woods (who i personally think largely benefited last year from Kupp being out) all to gain a 2020 1st.

It seems like if you are competing you are downgrading your starting lineup to pick up a 2020 1st

[killer_of_giants]

you slightly upgrade from pettis to woods (who i personally think largely benefited last year from Kupp being out)

and you think that based on what?
on the fact that woods' three 100+ yards games all came when kupp was playing perhaps?


on the trade, not so sure, i like your side more but i think it is fair. i think the "quality" of that first would influence my decision.

[Goddard]

Too many pieces being moved on both sides. What are you trying to accomplish with this trade? Can you simplify it a little and get what you really want?

[thomasscheeks]

You're giving up the best WR and the best TE. This is not a good trade even though you're getting some nice pieces back