Mixon or Package

[icy2]

I was approached today with a trade for joe mixon

Give: Mixon

Get: Tevin Coleman, Sutton, Godwin and 1.05

What y’all think? Team 1 in my sig

[ChefHerbie]

Hold Mixon

[AZCardsFan]

At first glance, I say hold mixon...but it is pretty even. Sutton and Godwin probably both worth a mid-late 1st each, so it’s like 3 1sts and Coleman for Mix. It’d help your depth out for sure but at the cost of your best RB.

Probably worth it if you could get Sanders or Montgomery at 1.05...

[icy2]

At first glance, I say hold mixon...but it is pretty even. Sutton and Godwin probably both worth a mid-late 1st each, so it’s like 3 1sts and Coleman for Mix. It’d help your depth out for sure but at the cost of your best RB. Guess I’d ask what your starting lineup requirements are...

Just added it to my sig but it’s 1qb,2rb,2wr,1te,2flex(rb/wr/te)

[Gator Sens]

Solid deal but I would hold Mixon. I see a solid argument for the package though too.

[lukkynumber13]

Solid deal but I would hold Mixon. I see a solid argument for the package though too.

Exactly.

This is a classic “trade calculator says it’s a win” that might not actually be enough for me to sell a stud.

Plus, one thing that may seem insignificant, is the fact that the one who receives all those lesser pieces now has to cut some players. If you’re not in an extremely deep league, that could bite you.

[Ron_Y]

I’d go for the package

[Finfansteve]

No way keep Mixon and build around him

[Jcedwards]

I’m super high on Mixon, so I’d hold him here.

[IR1]

With 2rb I’m holding Mixon

[jetsfan5757]

Toss up for me. I do like that you own Breida already in the event Coleman gets hurt. Minor factor, but it's nice.

Go with your gut.

[AresGodOWar2]

I love Mixon but thats a really nice deal , Godwin = 1.01 , Sutton top 5 pick for me , Coleman I dont really like but idk what he is going for , Plus the 1.05 , Its 3 early 1sts +..

Rebuild I would take the deal , Depending on my depth I might take the deal even if I'm trying to win now , If I was loaded and didn't need depth I would stick with Mixon

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

It's a nice package, but I'll take Mixon and the 3 extra roster spots.

[Pac_Eddy]

Yeah, that's a lot of roster spaces to give up. That's the hidden cost of a package deal. I'd hold with Mixon unless you're in a complete rebuild, then I might consider it.

[icy2]

Thanks for the input fellas. I didn't think about the 3 extra spots at the moment and respectfully declined the trade this morning. It would have been crazy to have to find 9 roster spots to cover the players in the trade and draft picks