Godwin vs Mack

[MadeinTC]

Team that lost in championship, 1 Qb:
Qb: mahomes, Stafford
Rb: kamara, kerryon, Mack, dalvin cook, j. Williams, Ballage.
Wr: diggs, Davis, Sutton, Lockett, Callaway, tre’Quan, Ridley, and desean Hamilton.
Te: Kittle, burton

A guy really wants Mack.


Offered Henry, but I said no.
Now offered Godwin, unsure if I can give up the depth.

I have 2 late 2019 1sts.

He has no 2019 picks, just 2020s.

Is a Godwin for Mack swap good for my team for win now? If Godwin would help is this a fair trade or should I ask for more cuz he really wants Mack?

$$$update: took Godwin +2nd in 2020.
Thanks for the input

[Johnny B. Goode]

Personally I like it. Godwin is top 20 easily. Mack very well could be drafted over in 2020

It's a matter of personal preference. You could ask for slightly more

[Beer Makes Me Smile]

I like Mack quite a bit for this upcoming season, but I think Godwin will be the better player over a 4 year span. I think you should ask for a small plus with Godwin.

[jomaed]

Is this PPR?

I would do either Henry or Godwin for Mack. But since he really wants him you should be able to get a bit more. I'd offer your worst 2020 second for his best 2020 1st on top.

[AresGodOWar2]

I moved Mack for Golladay so I would go Mack over Godwin

[Gator Sens]

I think Godwin is a bit more helpful for your build. I would try to get a pick added. I think both of these players are fairly even and both have a lot of hype heading into next year. RB's seem to carry more weight however, so i pick being added could happen.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I would need a late 1st / early 2nd added to Godwin to sell Mack or maybe Mack + 2nd for Godwin + 1st.

[BigBawseRoss]

mack way over godwin for a win now team but man you need wr badly i would look into ajg and ask his price. anyone older but gonna have solid production should be a target. hilton another good one.