Huge Kyler trade please help

[Brownies4life]

For team 2 was offered this. All opinions appreciated!

Give: Kyler Murray, Derius Guice, 2020 2nd (late projected)

Receive: Daniel Jones, Rashaad Penny, 2020 1st, 2020 1st (both mid to late projected)

[Gator Sens]

Not crazy about the deal. If you are not high on Murray or Guice however, this would be a solid deal. I feel Murray's value could go through the roof in SF.

[Phaded]

I think this is about even.
Value wise, I would take it.

If you are looking to compete this year, though - I think it hurts your chances as it leaves Flacco as your QB2.

[McCafsteez]

I would take the deal

[ChefHerbie]

No, I’d hold Kyler.

[Dynasty_Analyst]

Absolutely not in superflex your giving up the 2 best assets in the deal

[bdynomite]

So...a huge downgrade at QB and a huge downgrade at RB for a mid to late first and a 2 to 1 pick bump next year? I have no idea how people are advising you to take this. In a superflex, Kyler was probably your 1.01 this year, looks awesome and Guice is easily the next best piece. Decline.

[akpipeline23]

No way I do this - Kyler and Guice are worth much more than that.

[jwint7910]

Pass

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Murray alone >= the other side. Remove Guice and the 2nd and it's much closer.

[HughHoney]

Murray alone >= the other side. Remove Guice and the 2nd and it's much closer.

This

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

Easy no for me.
Kyler => Jones + late 2020 1st
Guice = Penny + late 20 1st
2nd > nothing

[surgebird2]

I'd remove the 2nd and take it. But I'd probably take it even with the 2nd as not a huge Guice fan and think Kyler is way overvalued right now.

Penny >= Guice + 2nd
Jones + 2 1sts >= Kyler

[Spongehack]

Easy no. Take out Guice and it's closer.

[BigBawseRoss]

hell yes i love that deal for your team in a 1 qb league this is penny and 2 firsts for giving up quice and swapping top 6 nfl draft pick QBs (one anointed the next big thing and one anointed the next big flop but nobody knows jack sh*t)