Lindsay/Jacobs trade *poll added*

[SWIMball]

Lindsay+2020 1st for Jacobs+2020 2nd. Which side would you prefer, and to what degree?

[FantasyFreak]

Really depends on what the rosters look like. I don't have much faith Lindsay ever repeats that season, especially with a wrist injury that severe. Unless it's basically guaranteed to be an early first, Jacobs. It could look bad if it ends up being Jacobs and 2.02 for Lindsay and 1.10.

[Gator Sens]

I would lean Jacobs because I think Lindsay takes a step back and Freeman takes a step forward.

[SWIMball]

Really depends on what the rosters look like. I don't have much faith Lindsay ever repeats that season, especially with a wrist injury that severe. Unless it's basically guaranteed to be an early first, Jacobs. It could look bad if it ends up being Jacobs and 2.02 for Lindsay and 1.10.

Based on our league, the first should be somewhere in the top 6. The second would be somewhere between 4&8.

[kellysheroes]

I would lean Jacobs because I think Lindsay takes a step back and Freeman takes a step forward.

I hope this is correct as a Freeman guy

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Gimme Jacobs + 2nd. Lindsay hasn't even started practicing yet at OTAs and will split time with Freeman regardless. I'd gamble on a potential workhorse back in an offense that added a lot of pieces this offseason.

[thomasscheeks]

Jacobs = full workload

Lindsay = timeshare

Jacobs side easy

[kmbryant09]

Jacobs = full workload

Lindsay = timeshare

Jacobs side easy

That's crazy because last time we saw Lindsay on the field, he was a...... WORKHORSE.

Last time we saw Jacobs on the field, oh that's right... He hasn't played a snap in the NFL.

[kmbryant09]

Gimme Jacobs + 2nd. Lindsay hasn't even started practicing yet at OTAs and will split time with Freeman regardless. I'd gamble on a potential workhorse back in an offense that added a lot of pieces this offseason.

Lindsay is practicing, just not taking full contact quite yet. He'll be full go by training camp so I don't expect his injury to be a factor moving forward.

[CrimeLord]

Lindsay side. He's proven it. I'll def gain valuable draft capital from someone who doesn't think Jacobs has downside too.

[Aldonall]

Definitely Lindsay side if it's a top-half 1st round pick on top next year. I know it's early, but that pick alone could end up being a Jacobs-tier RB. Plus, I think people undersell Lindsay. I'm aware history is against him, but he's already proven himself to be an extreme outlier, and I'm willing to gamble he continues to do so

[M-Dub]

Jacobs = full workload

Lindsay = timeshare

Jacobs side easy

That's crazy because last time we saw Lindsay on the field, he was a...... WORKHORSE.

Last time we saw Jacobs on the field, oh that's right... He hasn't played a snap in the NFL.

Not to mention, Jacobs wasn’t even a workhorse in college. This is the Lindsay side pretty easily for me. I see it as follows:

2020 early/mid 1st >/= Jacobs
Lindsay >>> 2020 mid 2nd

[jetsfan5757]

I like the Jacobs side. Not sold on Lindsay long term.

[FiremanEd]

Lindsay + 1st for me. Lindsay to Jacobs in 2019 will be moderate, while i view the pick delta for the years thereafter to be significant, assuming we aren't talking only a couple of picks difference (ie. bottom 2 1st vs top 3 2nd).

[SWIMball]

Lots of differing opinions here. Added a poll for simplicity