Poll: Who wins this trade? Hilton+ / Golladay

[elvisn]

Which side would you want?

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Golladay >= Hilton, so Hilton + 2.03 seems like fair value. Gimme Golladay if rebuilding and Hilton if contending.

Assuming it's for your Team 1 in sig, I'd keep Golladay. You have a lot of young talent, but not sure you're a true contender unless Davis, Godwin, and Henry all deliver on their hype.

[surgebird2]

Golladay >= Hilton, so Hilton + 2.03 seems like fair value. Gimme Golladay if rebuilding and Hilton if contending.

Assuming it's for your Team 1 in sig, I'd keep Golladay. You have a lot of young talent, but not sure you're a true contender unless Davis, Godwin, and Henry all deliver on their hype.

Agreed. It depends on whether you're rebuilding or contending.

[thomasscheeks]

I'm taking Golladay even if I'm contending.

TY's crazy target share will likely go down and Golladay could have a nice breakout this year. I wouldn't be surprised if they scored pretty similarly

[Gator Sens]

Golladay for me but it's very close

[smallxl]

I'm taking Golladay even if I'm contending.

TY's crazy target share will likely go down and Golladay could have a nice breakout this year. I wouldn't be surprised if they scored pretty similarly

I've said this 10 times already....Golladay is about to blow!

[Johnny Canuck]

Hilton for me. Guy has shown no signs of slowing down, and put up great stats last yr despite playing thru a high ankle sprain.

Every yr (except for Hiltons rookie yr), when he's played with Luck, he's put up over 1k in yardage...3/5 yrs with Luck he's put up more than 1270 yards. He's also never had less than 5 TDs in those 5 seasons.

Guy doesn't get enough credit in the fantasy community.

I like Golladay but I'd much rather have the better chance at winning weeks for the next 2-3 yrs. Forecasting any longer than that due to age is a dangerous game.

[jordanzs]

Fair trade. I have shares of them both. I took Hilton & the 2.3 and would hope to hit on a decent WR there.

[Johnny Canuck]

I'm taking Golladay even if I'm contending.

TY's crazy target share will likely go down and Golladay could have a nice breakout this year. I wouldn't be surprised if they scored pretty similarly

I've said this 10 times already....Golladay is about to blow!

What makes you guys think Golladay is going to break out next yr?

He has an new OC that is run centric, and even last yr when he was the man (literally the only good WR on the Lions due to injury) he still wasn't amazing. Now Hock is competitor for targets in the RZ, and Marvin isn't the slouch most make him out to be. I'm just not sure what I'm missing, but I'm open to having my mind changed regarding Golladay. So if you have some convincing info I'd be interesting in hearing it.

I like him, but the hype train seems to be rolling faster than it should imo.

[elvisn]

Thanks for all the input guys. This was a trade that I ended up taking. I really like Golladay and think he will be a monster, but, Lions will be run heavy this year, Hock and MJJ will demand targets, and Golladay isn't overly consistent. I have Davis and Godwin who I'm hoping for a breakout from, so in my mind, I wasn't going to be lucky enough to have 3 guys make that leap, so I wanted someone more consistent who I can depend on, and that was Hilton. I should get some decent pieces now through the draft to compliment my roster and I'm also trying to make a move for 1 more reliable vet WR at a reasonable price that can bail me out if Godwin/Davis don't make that leap.