Adams vs Thielen + ?

[Daltanian]

16 team superflex IDP, start 3-5 receivers.

Currently have Adams, Kupp, Hilton, Larry Fitz, Andy Isabella, and DeMarcus Robinson as notable receivers.

In the middle of the rookie draft, and was offered:

Thielen, a 2020 1st (likely in the 1.10-1.14 range), a 2019 mid 4th, and mid 5th.

I do like Thielen and in a 16 team league could use the other picks to help with IDP. However, it seems a little on the light side?

Any input would be appreciated. Thanks

[Mike from Canada]

It's not terrible but I don't think there is quite enough in it for you.

[lukkynumber13]

Have him change the 4th to a 2nd and then accept it.

[Daltanian]

Thanks guys. I'll have to see what I can swing. If the 1st was earlier I think I'd be more willing.

[Madcity_matt]

I’d much rather have Adams, I’d need more

[BelichekYourSelf]

Adams by quite a bit. A late 1st next year is not nearly enough to close the gap between them. Would need another significant piece added to even consider it.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Adams by quite a bit. A late 1st next year is not nearly enough to close the gap between them. Would need another significant piece added to even consider it.

x2 but to be fair, it's hard to expect the same mega trade value for studs in deeper 16-team leagues since everyone is hurting for depth. At the end of the day though, it's not enough to break up what has to be one of the best WR groups in such a deep format.

[Daltanian]

Adams by quite a bit. A late 1st next year is not nearly enough to close the gap between them. Would need another significant piece added to even consider it.

x2 but to be fair, it's hard to expect the same mega trade value for studs in deeper 16-team leagues since everyone is hurting for depth. At the end of the day though, it's not enough to break up what has to be one of the best WR groups in such a deep format.

If the 1st was more of a mid rounder, how much does that move the needle?

I'm attempting to get a little more added, but due to the reasons you mentioned it's tough in this size league to give up a ton of depth.

[Gator Sens]

Adams with the current trade structure

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Adams by quite a bit. A late 1st next year is not nearly enough to close the gap between them. Would need another significant piece added to even consider it.

x2 but to be fair, it's hard to expect the same mega trade value for studs in deeper 16-team leagues since everyone is hurting for depth. At the end of the day though, it's not enough to break up what has to be one of the best WR groups in such a deep format.

If the 1st was more of a mid rounder, how much does that move the needle?

I'm attempting to get a little more added, but due to the reasons you mentioned it's tough in this size league to give up a ton of depth.

I think I'd consider Adams for Thielen + mid 1st + early/mid 2nd. That'd be more or less equivalent value to Thielen + two 1sts in a normal 10 or 12-team format.

[lukkynumber13]

Adams??? OMGosh I’m an idiot.

I read it as ALLEN last night, like Keenan Allen

I would keep Davante Adams.