D. Hopkins for J. Jones/M. Mack

[BeeziBad]

Which side holds more value. Not for any sig team.
10 tm Dynasty nonppr.

[Gator Sens]

Hopkins for me. Julio is getting a bit older and his value is already dropping despite being the #1 WR in fantasy last year and Mack COULD only have value for a couple years. Hopkins value is not changing anytime soon.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Call me crazy, but I could see taking Julio + Mack for a contending team, especially in non-PPR. Seems pretty even to me. Realistically speaking, I'm not sure how many Julio owners would even be willing to add more than that for Hopkins.

[thomasscheeks]

This is Hopkins in any format, any situation. But in a ten man? This is Hopkins by a few hundred miles. Terrible offer

[abloom]

In a non-PPR I can see it being closer... in a 10 team however its Nuk

[Dizzle]

10 team league is all about the studs. Nuk is the only stud in that deal. Nuk wins by a mile.

[killer_of_giants]

In a non-PPR I can see it being closer...

no.

[abloom]

In a non-PPR I can see it being closer...

no.

yes.

[killer_of_giants]

In a non-PPR I can see it being closer...

no.

yes.

let's settle for "less far"?

[abloom]

no.

yes.

let's settle for "less far"?

That's just another phrase for closer. Glad to see you agree with me.

[jab3120]

Call me crazy, but I could see taking Julio + Mack for a contending team, especially in non-PPR. Seems pretty even to me. Realistically speaking, I'm not sure how many Julio owners would even be willing to add more than that for Hopkins.

I actually can agree with this, Julio is a top 5 WR but aging sure in 2-3 years you can find a replacement. Mack is upcoming and has plenty of potential. So a starting RB and a top 5 WR for Hop in Non-PPR, I say it's pretty close if not right on.

[BeeziBad]

Call me crazy, but I could see taking Julio + Mack for a contending team, especially in non-PPR. Seems pretty even to me. Realistically speaking, I'm not sure how many Julio owners would even be willing to add more than that for Hopkins.

I actually can agree with this, Julio is a top 5 WR but aging sure in 2-3 years you can find a replacement. Mack is upcoming and has plenty of potential. So a starting RB and a top 5 WR for Hop in Non-PPR, I say it's pretty close if not right on.

You’re nuts to think mack is ‘the man’ in that backfield. I may hold on to it this year but not very tight. A qb of lucks caliber deserves a stud and Mack is far from a stud. He’ll be gone before Julio. And obviously julio is short on time. Hop by a mile.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Call me crazy, but I could see taking Julio + Mack for a contending team, especially in non-PPR. Seems pretty even to me. Realistically speaking, I'm not sure how many Julio owners would even be willing to add more than that for Hopkins.

I actually can agree with this, Julio is a top 5 WR but aging sure in 2-3 years you can find a replacement. Mack is upcoming and has plenty of potential. So a starting RB and a top 5 WR for Hop in Non-PPR, I say it's pretty close if not right on.

You’re nuts to think mack is ‘the man’ in that backfield. I may hold on to it this year but not very tight. A qb of lucks caliber deserves a stud and Mack is far from a stud. He’ll be gone before Julio. And obviously julio is short on time. Hop by a mile.

[TroyH]

This is Hopkins in any format, any situation. But in a ten man? This is Hopkins by a few hundred miles. Terrible offer

x1,000

[kmbryant09]

I'm in the minority on this one.

For contending teams: Can't see them giving up Mack just to get a few years younger at WR. I think Julio can keep pace with Hopkins (and perhaps even outscore him) for the next few years. And Mack is likely penciled in on a lot of competing teams as a solid RB #2.

For rebuilding teams: You shouldn't really be consolidating assets in a rebuild, at least when those assets hold strong stand-alone value. For instance, I'd rather trade Julio for (2) 2020 1sts, and trade Mack for a 2020 1st and 2nd. To a rebuilding team, I think those picks would be more valuable in the long-haul than concentrating all that capital into 1 asset like Nuk.