Poll: Barkley, 1.04 OR luck, diggs and mixon

[smallxl]

1 pt PPR, 12 teams, 5 pt TD's for all

[makemeasandwich]

Give me the elite QB in Luck, top 5 upside in Mixon and the backend WR1 in Diggs.

[LMS123]

Being 1 QB it’s gotta be Barkley

[Gator Sens]

Luck side for me here

[BelichekYourSelf]

Barkley side very easily.

[Dynasty_Analyst]

I was going to say Barkley side before I saw the pick added with the 1.04 it's not close at all. Barkley

[surgebird2]

That's a really tough one for me. I think it's pretty fair, but really depends on team needs. With your team, I'd probably lean Luck/Mixon/Diggs side, but I wouldn't fault you either way.

[mmass]

How is this even close... I would take the Barkley side by a mile even without 1.04

[makemeasandwich]

How is this even close... I would take the Barkley side by a mile even without 1.04

Because he’s getting a top 8 RB and a top 12 WR, Diggs + Mixon would be a fair offer for Barkley straight up in my opinion.

[jenkins.math]

This trade makes a lot of sense for you, but I would keep the 1.04. You're not a contender in 12 team with or without the trade and that 1.04 would really help your squad. If he insists on a pick, give him your 2nd rounder.

[smallxl]

How is this even close... I would take the Barkley side by a mile even without 1.04

Because he’s getting a top 8 RB and a top 12 WR, Diggs + Mixon would be a fair offer for Barkley straight up in my opinion.

I always find it remarkable how much value people put on the top five assets in dynasty - and then poof - one day it's gone.

I was offered Christian McCaffrey and D Parker for my David Johnson in August. Boy I wish I had pulled the trigger on that one. To me, I almost never value One Player so much - although admit Barkley is the top dog right now. But if I could get Luck, Mixon and Diggs for him I don't see how I turn that down. I will not get a better offer than that. This is just something I am toying with at the moment. It's not even an offer on the table. Just going back and forth right now. I see these crazy "overpays" for players like Barkley but in the two leagues I am in that is Pie-in-the-sky - those deals rarely happen.

[Flgatorguy87]

5 point touchdowns has me on the Luck side

[DonBrazi]

5 point touchdowns has me on the Luck side

Not sure what that has to do with anything..

This trade can be looked at without Luck and the result should be the same (given that it's a 1QB league).

[JDogil12]

1.04>Luck
Quon=Mixon+Diggs
Close, but give me quon

[Goddard]

1.04>Luck
Quon=Mixon+Diggs
Close, but give me quon

I roughly agree with this valuation, but I think Mixon and Diggs would be slightly worth more than Barkley (or at worst equal to like you said). However, even in a 1QB league, I want that stud QB and think is probably worth more than the 1.04. This is a very close offer, but I prefer the Luck side.