Boyd vs DJ Moore

[jwb32]

What if anything needs to be added to Boyd? Newton situation concerns me but I'm looking to 2020 and beyond.

[Gator Sens]

It all depends on how the Moore owner views Boyd. If they are high on him, maybe an early 2nd gets it done.

[Ravens5220]

I would say they are fairly close, especially after Boyds 1k yards last year. So depends on how each feel about the player. I personally like Moore a lot more , but i am a biased Terp. Try for Boyd and either Lee, Edwards, or the 2.08. Depending on your feelings Miller, Robby A, Coutee could all be be in play as well

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

It all depends on how the Moore owner views Boyd. If they are high on him, maybe an early 2nd gets it done.

This seems about right. I wouldn't add more than that on top of Boyd for Moore.

[makemeasandwich]

Moore has the higher ceiling and metrics going for him, but Boyd has been more productive, should be a straight up swap on preference.

[Farley]

Moore has the higher ceiling and metrics going for him, but Boyd has been more productive, should be a straight up swap on preference.

Boyd's been more productive because he's been playing in the league for 3 years. His numbers dropped significantly last year once he lost AJG taking away the elite corners. No way I trade Moore straight up for Boyd.

[BigBawseRoss]

Moore has the higher ceiling and metrics going for him, but Boyd has been more productive, should be a straight up swap on preference.

Boyd's been more productive because he's been playing in the league for 3 years. His numbers dropped significantly last year once he lost AJG taking away the elite corners. No way I trade Moore straight up for Boyd.

could have sworn a different key player went down that might have impacted the passing game but i cant quite put my finger on it... do you recall??

it was Dalton the starting QB. in weeks 10-12 prior to being injured dalton had a combined 464 yards, 4 TD, 3 int.

i cant look down on boyd for that. meanwhile cam has had 1 dude ever be a relevant WR and that was big boy benjamin for 1 season.

[makemeasandwich]

If I could get Boyd + for Moore I'd do it.

[FantasyFreak]

Moore has the higher ceiling and metrics going for him, but Boyd has been more productive, should be a straight up swap on preference.

Boyd's been more productive because he's been playing in the league for 3 years. His numbers dropped significantly last year once he lost AJG taking away the elite corners. No way I trade Moore straight up for Boyd.

could have sworn a different key player went down that might have impacted the passing game but i cant quite put my finger on it... do you recall??

it was Dalton the starting QB. in weeks 10-12 prior to being injured dalton had a combined 464 yards, 4 TD, 3 int.

i cant look down on boyd for that. meanwhile cam has had 1 dude ever be a relevant WR and that was big boy benjamin for 1 season.

Steve Smith??? I think 1394 yards and 1174 yards in back back to years qualifies.

[Cowboysfan33]

I like Moore better long term but I don’t think there’s a huge difference either way.

[makemeasandwich]

The presence of that target vacuum CMC doesn't help.

[BigBawseRoss]

Boyd's been more productive because he's been playing in the league for 3 years. His numbers dropped significantly last year once he lost AJG taking away the elite corners. No way I trade Moore straight up for Boyd.

could have sworn a different key player went down that might have impacted the passing game but i cant quite put my finger on it... do you recall??

it was Dalton the starting QB. in weeks 10-12 prior to being injured dalton had a combined 464 yards, 4 TD, 3 int.

i cant look down on boyd for that. meanwhile cam has had 1 dude ever be a relevant WR and that was big boy benjamin for 1 season.

Steve Smith??? I think 1394 yards and 1174 yards in back back to years qualifies.

dude that was 7-8 years ago and Smith is one of the best receivers to ever play the game lol. those two seasons are also the highest passing totals newton has ever hit. i mean sure this does prove he can have a good wr i guess...

[Farley]

could have sworn a different key player went down that might have impacted the passing game but i cant quite put my finger on it... do you recall??

it was Dalton the starting QB. in weeks 10-12 prior to being injured dalton had a combined 464 yards, 4 TD, 3 int.

i cant look down on boyd for that. meanwhile cam has had 1 dude ever be a relevant WR and that was big boy benjamin for 1 season.

Steve Smith??? I think 1394 yards and 1174 yards in back back to years qualifies.

dude that was 7-8 years ago and Smith is one of the best receivers to ever play the game lol. those two seasons are also the highest passing totals newton has ever hit. i mean sure this does prove he can have a good wr i guess...

So your reason as to why Moore will not develop into a top WR is Cam Newton? But Boyd will be great unless he loses Andy F'n Dalton?

Steve Smith is not a good example of Newton supporting a WR1 because Smith was too elite a receiver? But Dalton's WR1, AJG, is pedestrian?

Those weak passing numbers you provided weeks 10-12 were without AJG and with Boyd. Kind of supports the argument that Boyd is incapable of solid production without Green.

[flashgordon12]

Moore has the higher ceiling and metrics going for him, but Boyd has been more productive, should be a straight up swap on preference.

Boyd's been more productive because he's been playing in the league for 3 years. His numbers dropped significantly last year once he lost AJG taking away the elite corners. No way I trade Moore straight up for Boyd.

He also was playing with Jeff Driskel... and still played well. Boyd is going to be a solid WR2/low end WR1 for a long time. So smooth. I would have him and Moore at about equal value, couldn't blame someone for going either way

[Jigga94]

I guess I'm just not that high on Boyd. I wouldn't move Moore for him without something pretty good added. Definitely not a 2nd in a weak class