Instant accept?

[hendo]

I give: D Guice+CJA+J Reynolds
I get: M Mack+A Miller+M Gesicki+2019 pick 32

This guy in my league has wanted Guice for a year now... Is this worth it?

[CurtisMyFavMartin]

I don’t see that as an insta accept at all. I’d keep Guice, unless you truly believe in Mack and that the Colts won’t sign Bell.

[GallifreyDoctor]

Hold. If he wants Guice, this offer will be on the table in April once you have a chance to see what the Colts do in FA/Draft

[jwb32]

Certainly not an insta accept. Mack is a risky trade target right now. His value hinges on whether or not Indy brings in another back. I'd hold Guice.

[hendo]

What about Guice for his 2019 1.05 pick and WR A Miller then?

[Panthers357]

I’d keep guice over the Mack offer and the 1.05 and Anthony Miller. I’d prefer Guice over the rbs in this class and Mack. The 2020 draft class seems to have better rbs.

[BiggieV]

Big part of this is FA and draft. If mack gets through both as RB1 at Colts then no question to me that value is on that side of the deal

[GallifreyDoctor]

Value-wise, Guice is still by far the best part of the package. He needs to give up an early 1st or WR better than CHI WR2 for you to consider. Guice is a top 10-15 RB in dynasty.

[Gator Sens]

Hold. Wait to see what you have in Guice. No reason to move him at this point.

[Jigga94]

I like every other piece you are getting back besides Mack. I guess if you wanted to flip Guice, it's fair but I would hold as well.

If Mack is the starter again he could easily out produce Guice...

[psfox2010]

I'd keep what you have.

[BigBawseRoss]

mack and 1.05 would be a done deal for guice.

i like mack as much as guice. i think it would be silly if they used big money on bell.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I don't know that it's an instant accept, but I'd take it. Mack + Miller > Guice for me.

[JessterC]

I am in a very similar situation, trying to trade Mack + Fitzgerald + 1.01 for Guice + 1.02. I am monitoring this thread carefully.

[JDogil12]

I'm keeping Guice at that price