Should I trade away Mixon?

[crip7300]

This is for team 4 in sig.

I just acquired Mixon in a trade, gave Aaron Jones, 1.04 and 2.05. I felt comfortable giving up the picks to upgrade from Jones to Mixon.
But now the same owner is trying to get Mixon back with an offer of Brandin Cooks and 1.04.

Here's my thoughts, I think it's a fair offer but I feel bellcow RBs win you championships and I think Mixon has the talent to jump up into the top tier of RBs. I'm not sure what I will be getting at 1.04 and Cooks has a ton of other weapons around him, so I don't ever see him being more than a top end WR 2, even though Cooks would be a nice fit on my team.

***Just got another offer for Mixon, the 1.02, 1.03 and a 2021 2nd. This is interesting as well.

What would be your preference? Thanks in advance.

[Pantherbro13]

Think you can fetch more for Mixon than that. I like Mixon much more than any of the rookies coming out. Instead of moving Mixon, I’d look to move Mack straight up for a WR.

[Favrezilla]

I'd only tradeaway Mixon if I got a big overpay and those are low offers imo.

[Gator Sens]

Mixon easily for me

[ajf235]

Wayyy too low for a potential top-5 RB.

[JDogil12]

I think the Cooks offer is reasoanble but I would keep Mixon

[Mike from Canada]

Cooks and 1.04 would tempt me but I think I keep Mixon.

[LMS123]

If the original owner traded him to you and realized they made a mistake and want him back I’d bet they’re willing to do a lot, milk it for as much as you can before even considering it

[Jigga94]

I like the Cooks deal for team 4. Try and get a 2nd added, but it's not a bad deal when you are already loaded at RB

[FantasyFreak]

NO! I don't like Mixon as a person, but a s a RB he's awesome. Team 4 you can start 5 RB's? Keep Mixon. You only have to start 2 WR's, DJ Moore will be an adequate WR2 with that team. If I could start up to 5 RB and had the 3 down Bell Cows you have in a 12 team league, I'd be holding those Gurley's, Mixon's etc with a vice grip.

Just look at your 5 RB's. You can start all 5 of them every week? Good lord. Stand pat, that's a championship caliber roster. You have a legit WR1, if DJ Moore can be a WR2-3 you're laughing, with Kittle at TE.

You have 2 top 5 scoring QB's, 4 RB 1's, and Mack would have been one on PPG. OBJ is a WR1, and DJ Moore and the rest of your WR's can adequately support that position considering you only have to start 2. Kittle at TE? Just sit back and win.