Saquon Offer Recieved

[24FlavorsofFun]

16-team Superflex.
1-2 QB, 1-5 RB, 1-5 WR, 1-5 TE (12 total starters)

Won the ship in year 1. Looking to sell a stud for a couple pieces to better fill out my lineup.

team approached my with the following:

I give: Barkley

I get: Chubb, TY or Amari, Ingram and Ebron.

Its a solid starting offer, but Barkley/Hill are near untouchable for me.

My team (players of note):

QB: Goff, Carr, Foles,
RB: Barkley, Drake, Lynch, D.Martin
WR: Brown, Hill, Evans, Tate,
TE: RSJ, Eifter

His players of note:

A-Rodge, Chubb, Ingram, D-Hop, TY, Amari, 19-2021 1sts.

[Paul717]

16-team Superflex.
1-2 QB, 1-5 RB, 1-5 WR, 1-5 TE (12 total starters)

Won the ship in year 1. Looking to sell a stud for a couple pieces to better fill out my lineup.

team approached my with the following:

I give: Barkley

I get: Chubb, TY or Amari, Ingram and Ebron.

Its a solid starting offer, but Barkley/Hill are near untouchable for me.

My team (players of note):

QB: Goff, Carr, Foles,
RB: Barkley, Drake, Lynch, D.Martin
WR: Brown, Hill, Evans, Tate,
TE: RSJ, Eifter

His players of note:

A-Rodge, Chubb, Ingram, D-Hop, TY, Amari, 19-2021 1sts.

Your TEs...by RSJ and Eifter do you mean ASJ and Eifert? Apologies if I misunderstood. But if that is correct, you have to at least consider a deal that brings back a decent RB, nice WR, and 2 TEs for 1 RB. Though I do love me some Barkley, I would make the deal based on your current TE construction.

[Gator Sens]

Even with the need for a TE, I don't think a Barkley package is the way to achieve that. Chubb is a great piece coming back but I would not even consider moving Barkley for this offer if I owned him. I don't think Ebron will ever match this season based on his catch to TD percentage. If it were Ertz or Kelce or Kittle, that would be different. I personally think owners are going to way overpay for Ebron this off season. Draft a TE.

[RB6]

I'm keeping Barkley here.

[The.Big.Spank]

As far as TE's go, I would rather take a flyer on Hockenson or Fant than pay for Engram and especially Ebron.

In fairness, you will find nobody who hates Ebron more than me on this forum. The guy should be the next Gronk, but he is totally content with coasting and just living off his athletic ability than learning a playbook, stretching to prevent injuries, working out or working on his hands.

[Gator Sens]

As far as TE's go, I would rather take a flyer on Hockenson or Fant than pay for Engram and especially Ebron.

In fairness, you will find nobody who hates Ebron more than me on this forum. The guy should be the next Gronk, but he is totally content with coasting and just living off his athletic ability than learning a playbook, stretching to prevent injuries, working out or working on his hands.

I'm with you on this one, I want nothing to do with Ebron.

[Kmani6]

I would seriously be considering this offer based on your roster. Realistically other than Saquon your RBs suck. Kenyan Drake is in a committee and clearly will not be a RB1, Lynch and Martin are worthless. You get back Chubb who will definitely return RB1 numbers (even if on the lower end) next year in an up and coming browns offense (can't believe I just said that). Mark Ingram will certainly be a RB 2 next year as he's signing his new contract, and people seem to forget his 2016 and 2017 stats were incredible. Lastly, you fill a hole at TE, because although Ebron could definitely regress, with the way the TE bunch looks right about now it'd be hard to argue he falls out of the top 5-7 TE next year. Lastly your WR are great in Hill and Evans, but AB and Tate are aging and grabbing Cooper would be a huge plus. I think you should keep the win now mentality and diversify Barkley into a lot of different assets, that can help your team win back to back for next year. Chubb, Ingram, AB, Tyreek, Evans, Cooper and Ebron seems absolutely SCARY in a 16 man league...

[jwb32]

You need a better return than this to consider moving Barkley.

[Jigga94]

Saquon Offer Declined

[Jigga94]

16-team Superflex.
1-2 QB, 1-5 RB, 1-5 WR, 1-5 TE (12 total starters)

Won the ship in year 1. Looking to sell a stud for a couple pieces to better fill out my lineup.

team approached my with the following:

I give: Barkley

I get: Chubb, TY or Amari, Ingram and Ebron.

Its a solid starting offer, but Barkley/Hill are near untouchable for me.

My team (players of note):

QB: Goff, Carr, Foles,
RB: Barkley, Drake, Lynch, D.Martin
WR: Brown, Hill, Evans, Tate,
TE: RSJ, Eifter

His players of note:

A-Rodge, Chubb, Ingram, D-Hop, TY, Amari, 19-2021 1sts.

Your TEs...by RSJ and Eifter do you mean ASJ and Eifert? Apologies if I misunderstood. But if that is correct, you have to at least consider a deal that brings back a decent RB, nice WR, and 2 TEs for 1 RB. Though I do love me some Barkley, I would make the deal based on your current TE construction.

He means Ricky Seales Jones. Still needs a TE

[FantasyFreak]

You need a better return than this to consider moving Barkley.

Chubb and Amari is is the way to go, not TY, IMO. I would try for something else other than Ebron and Ingram, but it's a solid starting point. I'd try and move Barkley for Chubb, Cooper and a better piece or two. As difficult as it is to trade a back of his caliber, Chubb is a talent as well, but I would need more as well.

[badbuddah]

People get dumb stupid sometimes in trades involving the top 1 or 2 players. Unless you have enormous depth, you likely can't afford to move two WR1, and an RB1 even for a Barkley. Like in my league a STARTING point would be Hopkins/Chubb/Ertz for Barkley. It is just too insane to ever consider trading for the #1 overall or #2 overall assets.

[makemeasandwich]

He's one man for god sake.... You likely won't get a better offer, as no one has the depth.

[24FlavorsofFun]

Agreed, offer is not enough.

May come with: Chubb/Hop/Ebron (Ebron is better than any TE I've got which is saying close to nothing)

Or just decline altogether.

[badbuddah]

Agreed, offer is not enough.

May come with: Chubb/Hop/Ebron (Ebron is better than any TE I've got which is saying close to nothing)

Or just decline altogether.

That offer you listed is more than fair imo. You get a low end RB1, high end WR1, and a solid TE.