Ertz/Guice trade

[zacharyringer12]

For team one in the sig, would you trade OJ howard and Derrius Guice for Zach Ertz and Tevin coleman? Upgrades my starting TE but lose a little RB depth. Thanks for the replies.

[heydangle]

No

[Jigga94]

Sounds like a free Tevin to me

Ertz = Guice and Howard

No? Maybe I'm just not that high on Guice as others. If anything, I think it's fair. Wouldn't blame you for declining if you love Howard as your TE1. I just know that Ertz is THE TE1

[Havok_21]

No..I prefer to keep Guice and Howard

[Motay316]

I think you go the side of Guice and Howard. I think that Guice will be a solid RB when he comes back and you got a young TE1 with Howard. Go with the side of youth and talent. Not sure what will become of Coleman but Guice is locked in as the RB1 with the skins.

[ajf235]

Ertz is a stud no doubt and he’s proven to not be injury prone, but OJ was putting up top 5 stud TE numbers before getting hurt last year and has nowhere to go but up. Guice has elite upside but may not be a true RB1 stud until 2020 given the state of the Redskins offense, I definitely think he’s far superior to Tevin Coleman unless Coleman lands in KC or Indy. I think this really comes down to personal preference, it sounds like a reasonable trade. I’d personally take the Guice/Howard side though.

[Titans95]

I'd lean Ertz. I like howard but by no means is he in the top 3 tier of TE's that give such a huge positional advantage.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

In a heartbeat. Ertz alone is worth Guice + Howard.

[diamonddave]

i think it's close but may slide over to the ertz/tevin side, esp if tevin can land in a good spot.

[MattDeezy]

I go Ertz side because:

Ertz is the only guy that we for sure know is a stud in this trade.

- OJHoward: How will Arians affect his value, as well as splitting with Brate still?
- Guice: Haven’t seen him in the regular season yet; who knows what he’ll be?
-Coleman: Where will he go and what will he do there?

Give me the known top TE + a gamble vs two gambles.