sony or chubb?

[playa_hata]

team 3 in signature. 12 team ppr superflex

I own sony and im a browns fan so i want to try to trade for chubb how much do i need to add to sony to get chubb. I think with sony's injuries chubb side wouldnt have to add. I offered sony for chubb straight up and got declined. i have 2 firsts and 2 seconds in this upcoming rookie draft. just curious how far off this trade is and how much needs added to sony side.

[PR0v3]

I prefer Sony to Chubb (very slightly), personally. I ignore injuries when making my player valuations though because I am of the mind that they will all get hurt a lot since they are playing football. Since I prefer Sony, I would pass on adding on anything to acquire Chubb.

[kris_kapsner]

I preferred Chubb to Michel by a slight margin in my rookie draft when I was facing both of them staring me in the face at pick 3 earlier this year. And I still prefer Chubb now, though admittedly earlier in this season I was worried I made the wrong choice. Now it looks like Chubb is going to be a better long term asset I think. But Michel is a good player in his own right.

You may have to add a 2nd to Michel to get "your guy".

[Jigga94]

I have Sony and I would swap straight for Chubb. No way I'm adding anything though

[BigBawseRoss]

you gotta ask him what he needs to close the gap. if its big walk away if its small send it.

[PercyR1]

I like them both about the same.

[joeya2001]

you gotta ask him what he needs to close the gap. if its big walk away if its small send it.

Giggity

[badbuddah]

As a Chubb owner I'd want a first. Chubb seems to be entrenched as the Browns RB of the future, and quite possibly he becomes a 3 down RB if they ship Duke. Michel is also a great RB, but I don't trust New England RBs, and wonder just how much longer that team will be in it's current format.

[Mjvb5]

you gotta ask him what he needs to close the gap. if its big walk away if its small send it.

Giggity

Thank you for pointing this out in the middle of lecture

Chubb for me by a decent margin, more than a 2 less than a 1

[colonnaj94]

Chubb is in the better situation, so I will take Chubb. I have Chubb as my 1.02 & Michel as my 1.05 right now, if that helps

[24FlavorsofFun]

I've got Chubb ahead of Sony for a few reasons. Two of which are situation (long-term is WAY better), and health (Sony already with knee issues).

Couple of 2's probably to get me to move Chubb.

[joeya2001]

you gotta ask him what he needs to close the gap. if its big walk away if its small send it.

Giggity

Thank you for pointing this out in the middle of lecture

Chubb for me by a decent margin, more than a 2 less than a 1

boyoyong

[Never Veto1]

I'd prefer Chubb and to switch sides would need at least a late 1st

[Titans95]

I don't understand why Chubb is in a better situation? Sony is getting as many carries as Chubb is getting and is on a more potent offense.

I lean Chubb if I could pick one but if I owned Sony I wouldn't add a thing to acquire Chubb. Both are producing rookies, both have knee issues, both are getting 20+ carries per game, both have solid receiving backs behind them.

[flyersfan1981]

I don't understand why Chubb is in a better situation? Sony is getting as many carries as Chubb is getting and is on a more potent offense.

I lean Chubb if I could pick one but if I owned Sony I wouldn't add a thing to acquire Chubb. Both are producing rookies, both have knee issues, both are getting 20+ carries per game, both have solid receiving backs behind them.

Brady files for Medicare this coming June I think...how much longer is that a potent offense when they lose him given the draft isn't likely to yield anyone good in the 20's.

I would need a mid-first at minimum to move Chubb for Sony. All these people saying they would take a 2nd are crazy. This draft is thin and the talent in the 2nd round is gonna be a coin flip at best. Chubb should feast without much competition for the next 3 years which is all you can ask for a RB.