Michel+ vs Guice+

[gogobradyarm]

I've been offered Guice and Minnesota Defense for my Michel and Browns Defense. I need a defense for the playoff push as i'm 7-3 and Jax D is playing terrible. Michel is better short term, but long term over Guice? I'm unsure. Thoughts?

[Favrezilla]

With your team I'd probably take Guice - chubb is already as good a backup...or cook....or kerryon if anything you should be trading for a better wr

[gogobradyarm]

With your team I'd probably take Guice - chubb is already as good a backup...or cook....or kerryon if anything you should be trading for a better wr

I'm happy with my WR's, but I see why you would say that. In comparison to my RB, my WR's are weak.

[vixen]

if anything you should be trading for a better wr

QB: Rodgers, Luck, Bortles
RB: Zeke, Conner, Chubb, Michel, Kerryon, Cook, Aaron Jones
WR: Hopkins, Adams, Allen, Diggs, Corey Davis, James Washington, Callaway
TE: Gronk, Engram, Njoku


Hopkins, Adams, Allen, Diggs, Davis...how much better can it get?
that is a really good team!

is the other team contending? if so, you need a 2nd on top of sony....he is contributing and we know what we get....guice is still an unknown

if not contending, then maybe a 3rd....

good luck

[dougw060]

With your team I'd probably take Guice - chubb is already as good a backup...or cook....or kerryon if anything you should be trading for a better wr

I'm happy with my WR's, but I see why you would say that. In comparison to my RB, my WR's are weak.

Your WRs are definitely not weak haha.

[dougw060]

I would take that deal. Not only does it help your defense but I believe in Guice more long-term.

[gogobradyarm]

I ended up taking the trade. I got Guice and Vikings defense and basically just gave up Michel. I like Michel a lot, but I do have my concerns around health of that knee long term (potential bone on bone/knee arthritis, due to an ACL rupture and multiple sprains/tears). Guice still very young and should make a full recovery, and that team seems to be supporting the ghost of Adrian Peterson. The biggest threat from the whole trade is the other team is in the hunt and could make a run now with Michel, but I'm still confident I can beat him.

[spotxc]

Your team is insane
I would of took guice also

[Dibbles]

Yep, crazy good team and good trade for you.

[gogobradyarm]

Your team is insane
I would of took guice also

Thank you. It only took two seasons of missing the playoffs to build this beast. Last year I actually scored most points in the league, but still didn't make playoffs lol. Feels great to finally be winning after two years of the league telling me my team sucks. Started at the bottom now we heeere

[bills2]

I don't really know much about the defenses, so it's Guice > Sony for me. I'd take Guice easily.