Ertz / Robinson trade

[WhiskeyRacer]

Hey All,

This is for my keeper team in signature.
.5ppr. keep 10 players.

Trade:
Ertz, 2018 pick 9
FOR
Robinson, 2018 pick 13.

The Allen Robinson owner is interested in acquiring Ertz from me. Ertz for Robinson straight up was not doing it for him, so I floated the idea of us swapping picks as well.
No commitments are made yet, Just wondering what others thought of this trade for my team as I am looking to compete and not sure if Robinson is a good fit or not yet.


Thanks!

[BigBawseRoss]

not doing it for him?! ertz over arob mane.

[WhiskeyRacer]

Yeah, that's what I thought at the time. Lots of question marks surrounding Robinson. Probably just the ghost of his WR1 potential making me second guess.

Seems like a classic case of one owner overvaluing their players.

[TTHTD]

Ertz is at the peak of his value. ARob stands to gain a ton of value this season and it's pretty safe to say his floor is a WR2 which insulates how far he can drop if he disappoints. Ertz>ARob atm but it's not a bad trade imo. More to gain than lose

[Goddard]

I might do it straight up, but wouldn't add anything to Ertz side.

[notweswelker]

I prefer to keep the two TEs.

[thomasscheeks]

Ertz > ARob
9th > 13th

This is pretty lopsided...

[WhiskeyRacer]

Thanks for all the input. I'm going to keep Ertz!

[Mr. Wizard]

I love ARob and think he's got great potential to bounce back, but in terms of being a fantasy difference maker, I think there are a solid batch of wide receivers that can give you what Robinson will, and one or two tight ends that will give you what Ertz will. I go Ertz.