Melvin Vs Adams

[pack4ever22]

Been a while since I've posted on these forums but really need a 2nd opinion on this one.

For a championship team full ppr, 2RB 2WR 3FLEX I have been offered the following:

Devante Adams, Geronimo Allison, John Kelly, 2nd
for
Melvin Gordon, Kalen Ballage

My Roster is

Cam, Alex Smith
Gurley, David Johnson, Kamara, Melvin, Dion Lewis, Cohen, Ballage
Hopkins, DT, Josh Gordon, Godwin, Golladay, John Brown, Anthony Miller, Dante Pettis
Kelce, OJ Howard

I'm tempted because I would like to strengthen my WR position but with the flexibility of our starting requirements I really don't see it as a huge issue, meanwhile its going to be a lot of fun trotting out my top four RBs on a weekly basis. Its tough for me because I do really like both players.

[BigBawseRoss]

seems fair

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Adams > Gordon + Ballage
2nd > nothing

Easy accept

[Flatlander19]

I would take the Adams side. You are set at rb without gordon

[Goddard]

Adams and Gordon are close for me. I think I'd rather have the 2nd alone over Ballage.

[hudini33]

I have Gordon and Adams close, but with your roster, I'm taking Adams here because you even get Gurleys backup

[GreenAndWhite81]

I have Gordon and Adams close, but with your roster, I'm taking Adams here because you even get Gurleys backup

Agreed.

[Dunville]

I’m huge on Adams and I believe he’ll jump into top 5 WR rank this year. So it’s a massive win imo.

It also makes sense for your team Given your strength at RB

[Titans95]

Adams is an instant starter and will be more relevant for longer than Gordon will, Gordon is your RB4....trading a bench player for a stud starter is always a good idea.

[pack4ever22]

Adams is an instant starter and will be more relevant for longer than Gordon will, Gordon is your RB4....trading a bench player for a stud starter is always a good idea.

Not a bench player. Our starting requirements allow me to start up to 5 rbs on a weekly basis, and I did so regularly last year.

[notweswelker]

I have Gordon and Adams close, but with your roster, I'm taking Adams here because you even get Gurleys backup

That end piece makes the trade for me too.