Team Assessment / Trade Advice

[SkinZ187]

This is NOT for the team in my sig!

Looking for an honest assessment on this team, and advice on the current trade offer i have.

This is a 30 man roster, 10 team, PPR league with 4 pt passing TD's
Here are the starting requirements:

2 QB, 3 RB, 4 WR, TE, K, Def and 1 additional flex spot that can be rb/wr/te. Most people including myself will usually start 5 WR's. As you can see, we have very deep starting requirements. Also, next season we move MUST start 2 TE.

My current roster, with starters in bold

QB - Stafford, Keenum, Trubisky, Josh Allen, McCarron, Bridgewater

RB - Dalvin Cook, Jerick Mckinnon, Guice, Latavius Murray, Rawls, Breida, Lacy

WR - Odell, Julio, Ridley, Martavis Bryant, Jermaine Kearse, Boyd, Dorsett, Ellington, Maclin, Lockett, Treadwell, Wallace, Terrance Williams

TE - Rudolph, Akins, Josh Hill, Jerell Adams

As you can see, i dont have alot of depth behind by starters -- bye weeks and any injuries to starters is going to take a toll. This team finished 2nd to last in 2017. I have NO first round picks in 2019 and just my single first rounder in 2020.

Current offer is I give Julio + Derrius Guice for FIVE first round picks. 4 of these picks are in 2019, one of which will most likely be the 1.01. As far as the other 3 first rounders, they could fall anywhere. In addition to these 4 2019 first rounders, I would get another first rounder in 2020.. no idea where the 2020 first will fall.

Should i reload with the 5 first rounders, or try to compete this coming season? Also, please give me an honest assessment of the current state of this team.

Thanks for any and all advice!!!

[moishetreats]

I think that you're spot-on with your thinking: You have some good/great/elite players, but your team isn't deep enough to win in the regular season let alone the playoffs.

I also second the idea of moving Julio. It looks like you need to include Guice in order to get a ransom for Julio. But, if that's the cost of doing it, then go for it. I'd look to take back a couple of flyers from the other guy. Maybe a TE that he's not starting (Butt, ASJ, something like that) and/or an upside WR flyer (R. Anderson, someone like that). I wouldn't lose the deal over this, though.

Basically, I think that you're entirely on the right track here in your own team assessment as evidenced by the trade that you're considering -- and that I would take.

Good luck!

[Goddard]

I don't see this team competing this year, but it's got some nice pieces to build around. If one of those 1sts is projected to be the 1.01 like you said, I'd probably make that trade and try to retool.

[playa_hata]

kind of suprising this team wasnt dead last last year considering you lost odell and dalvin... but if you make this trade i would sell mckinnon immediately too or even better try to see if buddy will do this trade with mckinnon instead of guice!

[darewood11]

kind of suprising this team wasnt dead last last year considering you lost odell and dalvin... but if you make this trade i would sell mckinnon immediately too or even better try to see if buddy will do this trade with mckinnon instead of guice!

I like this idea the best. I definitely do this deal tho.

[Go Bucks]

I think you have to take the deal. Your team is in rough shape for a 10-team league. Would also think about moving Keenum or Allen for a TE to prepare for the switch to being a 2 TE league.

[SkinZ187]

Another important factor I forgot to mention, is that this league is NOT head to head... it is an “All Play” league. If Julio and Guice leave this team, One of the 2019 1st rounders will most certainly be the 1.01