Hilton+ for Adams

[keller569]

Thinking of throwing this out to an owner. Want to make sure I make a fair offer, so that at worst I get a counter. I'm just trying to consolidate some talent.

Hilton, Watkins, Hines

or

Adams

[Krang]

Hines is negligible here, so it's essentially Hilton and Watkins for Adams, which I think might be an overpay but not to the point where I couldn't live with it if I wanted Adams.

[notweswelker]

I think it's a fair offer, but I chose the Adams side.

[Farley]

I like the Hilton/Watkins/Hines side by a bunch.

[Titans95]

Think its a pretty even offer, its mainly if you believe Luck will be healthy and if Watkins has a real shot at being what everyone wants him to be. Personally I think Adams is a top 5 dynasty WR at this point but I think TY has a lot of juice left if Luck is back and I also think Sammy is better than people give him credit for

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

It's pretty fair. Depends on whether or not that owner needs WR depth though.

[skip]

I'd rather own Hilton than Adams...

[Titans95]

I'd rather own Hilton than Adams...

[msdeac]

Hilton + Watkins...

[BigBawseRoss]

this is absurd. this MIGHT be the price IF Adams had ever had a top flight season... you are suggesting paying the price of what you hope he is going to become rather than paying the price for what he is.

[keller569]

For what it’s worth, I went ahead and offered the trade for Adams. I was told, “Not close.”

[JJRules]

That's a fair enough offer, but there's no way I would accept it.

[Johnny Canuck]

For what it’s worth, I went ahead and offered the trade for Adams. I was told, “Not close.”

Well maybe it'll be the best deal you never made. Now that Luck is throwing, you can count on him targeting TY non stop this yr (as he's pretty much the only option). I forecast a top 10 WR season coming from TY this yr.

For what it's worth, I own both, TY and Adams, and don't know what I would do if that was offered to me. I see it as 50/50 and really dependent on overall team depth.

[Titans95]

this is absurd. this MIGHT be the price IF Adams had ever had a top flight season... you are suggesting paying the price of what you hope he is going to become rather than paying the price for what he is.

25 year old with back to back WR1 years tied to the best QB in football? That is going to cost a pretty penny to acquire just saying. I think we can both agree rodgers is locked for around 35 touchdowns....where are all of those going to go? Rookies? Cobb and Graham may take around half of them.... maybe 5ish to running backs? That leaves 12 touchdowns up for grabs between rookies and the #1 go to on their team that's scored 10+ touchdowns the past 2 years. Very few WR's in the nfl can you count on having 10+ touchdowns and Adams is one of them.

[24FlavorsofFun]

Not a Sammy fan so I'm taking Davante.

With Jordy out of the way he's in line for a huge career year.