McCoy for Wentz +?

[joeylitz]

I give MCoy
I receive Wentz

He’s offering Wentz + Joe Williams
Or Wentz plus a draft pick. He’s a buddy of mine and I want to make sure this is a fair trade. What’s fair?

[mariettajeff]

Having to start 2 RR's, I'd keep McCoy.

[joeylitz]

Having to start 2 RR's, I'd keep McCoy.

I think I’m ok with McKinnon as my RB2

[Champ224]

I'd keep McCoy too...QBs look solid to me...if you want Wentz why not package something with Winston? Trading McCoy leaves you no RB depth

[joeylitz]

I'd keep McCoy too...QBs look solid to me...if you want Wentz why not package something with Winston? Trading McCoy leaves you no RB depth

1) eagles fan so would like to have Wentz
2) McCoy is old. I’m worried about getting something for him while I still can
3) I need a plan to replace Brees and I don’t feel like it will be Winston

If McKinnon doesn’t work out, i could still trade draft picks for another RB.

So given that, what’s proper compensation? That’s really what I’m interested in

[SHIZZLE]

I like the McCoy for Wentz value, but you don't really need wentz. It is nice having 2 young QB's for the next 10 years though. Selling shady is a good idea about now. Maybe he has one good season left.

Compensation: I don't know his RB needs, to make it fair you have to value players based on each team needs. You don't need a QB, but I am assuming he needs a RB. therefor, he needs to pay-up to get McCoy. I own McCoy and would do it for Wentz and a 3rd or a good RB prospect (not named joe Williams).

My team is going to need another QB in the next few years, and I have some RB depth, but I would do McCoy for Wentz and a lil more.

[topher]

I think the offer is fair.....if the other guy was desperate for a RB, I'd maybe try to squeeze out more, but since you say its a buddy, I think straight up is fine. I'm going to assume if he wants McCoy for Wentz it means he thinks he can win.

I also agree to moving McCoy while you can still get value.

[R2D2]

I think the offer is fair.....if the other guy was desperate for a RB, I'd maybe try to squeeze out more, but since you say its a buddy, I think straight up is fine. I'm going to assume if he wants McCoy for Wentz it means he thinks he can win.

I also agree to moving McCoy while you can still get value.

x2

[mariettajeff]

According to the players you listed, you don't have McKinnon, but you do own Riddick. A slight difference.

[topher]

According to the players you listed, you don't have McKinnon, but you do own Riddick. A slight difference.

I didn’t catch it at first glance but he’s listed as flex

[21TD]

Value is fair. I'd get a q.b. later but you seem confident, go for it and might be set at q.b. 8+ yrs

[blacklab1010]

I would do this trade easily, and then trade brees or winston+ for a rb

[SpartacusPTech]

I'd rather have Wentz over McCoy, so not sure why the Wentz side would have to add.

Take Wentz and worry about your lineup later. Still months before the season starts.

[Titans95]

I'd take Wentz over Mccoy in a 1qb startup so yes I'd make this trade. McCoy is 30...AP, Murray, JC just to name a few that fell off the deep end at 30 and completely lost any value at all, if you can get the QB2 in dynasty formats for him right now go ahead and do that for sure.

[Duke Nuk’em]

Add Winston and see if you can get something better than Joe Williams.