Bell ++ or McCaffery/Hunt

[TheBum]

Thoughts on a better Value in a Ppr? Nervous about 2nd year players versus the proven monster bell.

[topher]

I would chose Luck

Bell > Hunt
Hyde < CMC (But I think Hyde is under rated, I'm starting to really like him and I don't fully trust CMC durability)
Luck > Wentz
Free 2.08

[TheBum]

I would chose Luck

Bell > Hunt
Hyde < CMC (But I think Hyde is under rated, I'm starting to really like him and I don't fully trust CMC durability)
Luck > Wentz
Free 2.08

Thank you! Agree with the breakdown but still think Wentz > Luck.

[Gator Sens]

This is a tough call but I think simply Bell is the best player in the deal. Hunt and McCaffery are both a bit of a question mark until they prove to be consistent year to year as Bell has. I think Wentz is another huge piece in the deal but again does not have the year to year production just yet. For me, there are just too many unknowns to move Bell in this deal.

[topher]

I would chose Luck

Bell > Hunt
Hyde < CMC (But I think Hyde is under rated, I'm starting to really like him and I don't fully trust CMC durability)
Luck > Wentz
Free 2.08

Thank you! Agree with the breakdown but still think Wentz > Luck.

Ya, totally understand, it's not by much honestly, it's really close for me.

[HughHoney]

Close. I see it:

Bell>Hunt
Hyde+2.08<CMC
Luck<Wentz

Overall, pretty even to me.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

I think its fair... comes down to what Luck is... I see him still as a top 5 fantasy QB, then he is similiar as wentz and I would take the deal, otherwise if you see luck more in the winston range then I would take the other side

[Goddard]

Bell side with Luck by a lot.

[Ghosted]

There's a few league considerations here, and it's probably close enough that it would come down to team specifics. I agree it's close though. Value is probably slightly on the Hunt side.

[skip]

At this point Wentz and Luck are a push if not favoring Wentz by a little. As a duo, I'd feel better with Hunt/McCaffrey going into a season than Bell/Hyde but I don't think much of Hyde.

[vixen]

wow, this is super close...i think i like the Bell side, but can make an argument for the other side....it depends on how comfortable you are that Bell will remain out of trouble for the next 3/4 years....
good luck

[The.Big.Spank]

I would chose Luck

Bell > Hunt
Hyde < CMC (But I think Hyde is under rated, I'm starting to really like him and I don't fully trust CMC durability)
Luck > Wentz
Free 2.08

Thank you! Agree with the breakdown but still think Wentz > Luck.

All of this

[Suhmdog]

I easily pick luck with bell and Hyde

[RB6]

Bell side. With Luck.

[DBass218]

Bell is the best player in the deal by a good bit. I always lean towards the best player so I got he Bell side pretty easily here.