Corey Coleman - Value Check - Is he done?

[Prospector]

I am having a tough time in valuing this player. Had great potential, been injured a ton, terrible catch rate and just had that horrific drop. Is there more to see with this guy?

I cannot find much on him besides some heavy hate on Twitter ATM.

[lukkynumber13]

I'd still pay any 2nd rounder for him. I think he has real talent, just some very real flaws and part of a terrible organization as well.

[Mrowmix]

I still like him. I'd give up a very late first for him. That drop against the Steelers is being so overblown. Degen fanbase if they are scapegoating him instead of focusing on the 1-31 Hue Jackson. (Over 30 losses in two seasons!)

[Goddard]

Probably a 2nd. Hasn't stayed healthy and hasn't produced when he plays. Can't justify paying a 1st right now.

[block2323]

I owned him and would be happy to get a late first/early 2nd for him. Realistically probably worth an early second to mid second at this point.

He has the talent, just needs the right situation.

[Bot101]

I owned him and would be happy to get a late first/early 2nd for him. Realistically probably worth a early first to mid second at this point.

He has the talent, just needs the right situation.

Hes worth an early 1st?

[block2323]

I owned him and would be happy to get a late first/early 2nd for him. Realistically probably worth a early first to mid second at this point.

He has the talent, just needs the right situation.

Hes worth an early 1st?

Haha meant to say early second to mid 2nd. Thanks for catching that. I voted early 2nd.

[Factory of Sadness]

As a Browns fan I've sadly come to understand that looking like crap for the Browns doesn't mean very much. You're as well off ignoring Coleman's pro career and evaluating him on his college tape whilst factoring in a couple of broken bones and a totally understandable lack of enthusiasm for the bleep Hue shovels. You might lose in buying him for a high second, but the process makes sense. Dumping a guy you took in the top 5 of the draft who has been banged up for two years and playing in Cleveland for less than that strikes me as short-sighted.

[MucBuc]

As a Browns fan I've sadly come to understand that looking like crap for the Browns doesn't mean very much. You're as well off ignoring Coleman's pro career and evaluating him on his college tape whilst factoring in a couple of broken bones and a totally understandable lack of enthusiasm for the bleep Hue shovels. You might lose in buying him for a high second, but the process makes sense. Dumping a guy you took in the top 5 of the draft who has been banged up for two years and playing in Cleveland for less than that strikes me as short-sighted.

Agreed. Too early to write him off before we could actually see him play with even an average NFL QB and with a better supporting cast. That being said, as a owner I would sell for a late 2018 first, but probably not for 2nd rounder.

[pierson242]

I'd still pay any 2nd rounder for him. I think he has real talent, just some very real flaws and part of a terrible organization as well.

x2

[Jak]

is Corey Coleman the new Kevin White??

[bot]

If you can get him for a 2nd I would say do it all day. Someday he has to get to play with a competent QB

[BigBawseRoss]

hes gotta stay healthy and pray the team gets a better qb...him and gordon are a great 1-2 punch

[Goddard]

is Corey Coleman the new Kevin White??

Lol I hope not for his sake, but there are a lot of similarities.

[lukkynumber13]

is Corey Coleman the new Kevin White??

No, that's disrespectful to Coleman haha

Coleman has at least had multiple blowup weeks. White has never had a single game where he looked good.