Fournette for Antonio Brown?

[whodunnit]

one of the top WR to play the game in the last 5 years or so that can continue producing at an elite level, or a oft-banged up RB? (Who I also believe to be overrated)

take Brown and send him a thank you card.

[block2323]

I think an argument can be made for either side here. Non-PPR favors fournette while your starting requirements favors Antonio. I don't think you can go wrong either way here but fournette seems like an injury concern going forward with his ankles. I would go Antonio to help out your starting lineup and try to win it all since that is the goal!

[esloan35]

AB is just too good to pass on.

[JIBaseball04]

Antonio Brown without a doubt regardless of format.

[Finfansteve]

Wow guys I’ve gotta say the amount and quality of responses to my question as a first time poster is much appreciated! Other forums I’m on probably would have gotten me 2-4 answers of “yes” or “of course” or “no”.
Anyhow I appreciate all the answers as you all know sometimes you get locked into your own ideology and need outside unbiased opinions to make a good decision on players.
My biggest concerns were possible Ben retiring and who would replace him, Browns age, Juju’s potential impact in the future vs Fournette’s youth, it looking like the Jags want to build their offense around him, and he’s on an ascending team which should get him more opportunities for yardage and scores down the road, not to mention the age difference between the two of the players (usually I’m the one trading aging stars for young ascending talents). Also I won the league championship without AB and if my wrs decide to play like they can next year I should be in position to win again barring strange occurrences but I want to give myself the best chance of repeating next year so when I saw the trade offer I knew I had to go on a different forum (AB owner is on most of the forums I’m on and I didn’t want him to see if the trade was overwhelmingly possibly in my favor and pull it).

Anyhow thanks for the responses this is now my go to dynasty question forum

[Finfansteve]

He just reached out to me by text. This owner also owns Hopkins and now has offered me Hopkins for Fournette and Josh Gordon.
Which trade is better for me or are they equal?
Fournette for AB

OR
Fournette/Gordon for Hopkins?

Thanks!

[DLF_Pierson]

He just reached out to me by text. This owner also owns Hopkins and now has offered me Hopkins for Fournette and Josh Gordon.
Which trade is better for me or are they equal?
Fournette for AB

OR
Fournette/Gordon for Hopkins?

Thanks!

I'm not a huge Josh Gordon guy so I would take Hopkins

[FKC]

Goodbye Fournette.

AB will help your a lot more than Fournette will for the next few years. Ben possibly retiring makes it a little risky of course, but this is Antonio Brown we're talking about. I would have to accept this

Hahahaha! Well said. Goodbye!

[HughHoney]

Definitely AB for me.

[thomasscheeks]

He just reached out to me by text. This owner also owns Hopkins and now has offered me Hopkins for Fournette and Josh Gordon.
Which trade is better for me or are they equal?
Fournette for AB

OR
Fournette/Gordon for Hopkins?

Thanks!

Oh man, jump all over that. Gordon barely exists in this trade, you're basically trading Fournette for Nuk. Great trade for you

[IR1]

Nuk for me- young and elite

[DinoDynasty]

I'd take either of those trades given your team makeup.

[NY CAT]

LF for me.
Young back just hitting his prime will be centerpiece of Jax offense.

AB is the best in the wr world however, some uncertainty regarding Big Ben looms large.

[QuintorrisLopezJones]

He just reached out to me by text. This owner also owns Hopkins and now has offered me Hopkins for Fournette and Josh Gordon.
Which trade is better for me or are they equal?
Fournette for AB

OR
Fournette/Gordon for Hopkins?

Thanks!

I was actually going to say I would much rather pair LF + CD/TY/Gordon and even overpay if needed for one of Nuk or OBJ. Regarding AB, I love the idea of trading LF for a WR, but ideally it wouldn't be for one who is a bit older to pair with Julio. Also, IF you were going to do the AB trade, definitely wait until we figure out what Ben is doing. If he retires this year, this looks like a horrible deal.

That being said, take the Nuk offer now. I'd be happy paying a good amount more than what hes asking.

[HughHoney]

Didn’t see the Hopkins offer earlier. I would take that offer.