Trade Watkins straight up for A. Smith?

[jojo5151]

For team 1 in sig

Must win situation & my QB's a shaky Rivers post concussion or Cutler (meh).

Should I consider trading Watkins for A. Smith straight up? All other offers I've made involving Watkins have been turned down but Smith might be "getable" & he has a pretty good stretch schedule.

Yay or Nay?

[BradysBunch]

That is an overpay. Can you try picks? I gave up two 4th rds and Chad Williams for Smith 3 weeks ago.

[vixen]

you only show a roster of 17 players (and 3 of those are Defenses)..i can't believe that there is nobody on the ww to pick

i think it is also an overpay, if you think it will help you win $$ then go for it ....but i would ask for a pick to go with smith

[Suhmdog]

Absolutely Not, you can do better and if not thn it's not worth it

[Generic Username]

PLEASE offer me your Watkins for my A Smith! I've been trying to move him in a rebuild and best offer I've gotten is M Lynch...in a rebuild!

I'm not gonna argue with any owner who's just "done" with Sammy; I own him a few places and can relate to needing now vs promises for tomorrow. But I wonder if he can't still pull a bit more return, like Cam or Russell? In the end, though, would easily see why making this specific move works for you

[smoppelpoppel]

Nay, roll with Rivers. Too much for Smith.

[Broncopain]

I know how it feels when you see a need but he would need to bring something else to the table besides Smith to do that deal. A solid wr prospect or first for me. Even then it could be tough.

[vbbish]

Feels like a huge loss in value. Remember KC traded up to pick his replacement in the first round. How long before they hand it over.

[Goddard]

When I read the title, I was sure this was going to be for a 2QB league, and even then I wasn't sure which side I'd go with. In a 1QB league, Watkins is still worth much more than Smith.

[lukkynumber13]

I don't care how low you are on Sammy, this is a heck no to the extreme