First year Superflex trade question

[Cowboysfan33]

This is my first year playing in SF leagues and I joined two, so I'm definitely inexperienced. Anyway, between the draft and waiver wire in one of my SF leagues, I've got Brady, Carr, Watson/Savage, Cutler and Hoyer. So, I put Hoyer on the trading block and got an offer of Randall Cobb for Hoyer & Marlon Mack. I'm not going to trade Mack so that's out of the question but is Cobb for Hoyer close or should I ask for more? I understand that QBs are so important but even though I think Hoyer is kinda valuable this season, I would expect him to replaced for sure by next season, so any feedback/insight would be appreciated. I need WR help pretty bad in that league.

His WRs: Cooper, Watkins, CoCo, Snead, Cobb, Taywan, Wallace

My WRs: AJG, Baldwin, Garçon, John Brown, Agholor, JuJu

[Slackalacker]

I think you can get better out of Hoyer. He doesn't have any competition really as of right now and honestly shouldn't, Hoyer can lead a good team to a wild card spot and a mediocre team to an 8-8 season.

I'd hold until someone's QB goes down, then they'll be willing to give up more for him.

Edit: How man WR do you start? I am higher on Snead than Cobb due to age and lack of injury history. I may be willing to ship Hoyer for Snead if you're really desperate at wr

[Cowboysfan33]

I think you can get better out of Hoyer. He doesn't have any competition really as of right now and honestly shouldn't, Hoyer can lead a good team to a wild card spot and a mediocre team to an 8-8 season.

I'd hold until someone's QB goes down, then they'll be willing to give up more for him.

Edit: How man WR do you start? I am higher on Snead than Cobb due to age and lack of injury history. I may be willing to ship Hoyer for Snead if you're really desperate at wr

We only have to start 2 WRs. We start a total of 9 players between QBs, RBs, WRs and TEs. No kickers or defenses.

[Slackalacker]

I think you can get better out of Hoyer. He doesn't have any competition really as of right now and honestly shouldn't, Hoyer can lead a good team to a wild card spot and a mediocre team to an 8-8 season.

I'd hold until someone's QB goes down, then they'll be willing to give up more for him.

Edit: How man WR do you start? I am higher on Snead than Cobb due to age and lack of injury history. I may be willing to ship Hoyer for Snead if you're really desperate at wr

We only have to start 2 WRs. We start a total of 9 players between QBs, RBs, WRs and TEs. No kickers or defenses.

In superflex leagues I know Starting QBs, no matter the caliber, tend to warrant first round picks.

I'd most likely be willing to move Hoyer for a 2018 or 2019 1st round pick. Your QBs are set for awhile I doubt you'll even have to use Hoyer so I'd be okay selling him for the future.

[Goddard]

Hoyer should have a 2nd round value. Cobb isn't a terrible return, but I'd wait and see if you can get more... maybe early during the season.

[Cowboysfan33]

Okay, thanks guys. I'll probably just wait because that's the only offer that I've received so far and I would think some of the other teams will get desperate after a few weeks.

[vixen]

i agree on the 2nd round value of Hoyer....with your team, i would be willing to gamble Cobb for Hoyer.


since the guy originally thought you should add to your side, i doubt that you will get much more...but doesn't hurt to ask for an additional 3rd round pick....i would certainly not add anything to your side.

personally, i would rather have cobb (over snead) but that may just be preference