Dynasty League Football Forum

For team 1 in sig...have Alshon and trying to determine if I should move him for Moncrief and a random 1st? How does the forum feel about Moncrief going forward?

I have a hard time determining who is the bigger tease, him or Watkins

I'd probably roll the dice with Moncrief and the 1st. I think Alshon's best days might be behind him.

Alshon if you're a contender or if the 1st is projected late. I don't like Moncrief much, so if I did this trade, I'd want to flip him for something else.

Just recently dealt Moncrief for the 2.04 rookie pick.

This meant I'm keeping Garçon over Moncrief

Alshon any day or format. Even with a first unless it's guaranteed top3-4

I also really dislike moncreif .

I like moncrief.. Alshon is another Sammy at times.. doI would lean that way

I prefer Alshon over Moncrief.

I worry about Moncrief relying too heavily on TDs which might not come this year

They're both injury prone, but alshon looks healthy and fit for a change. I kinda feel like they're very similar in production.... If healthy. I'd probably lean alshon ever so slightl if I wanted to compete this season, but they both carry a certain degree of risk. I guess for me the kicker would be where you project the first round pick to range. Top 3-4, or later? Also, I like the Luck to Moncrief pairing over the Wentz to Alshon combo, so maybe the qb could help in deciding. However, Moncrief is in the final year of his deal. I guys for me it's all going to hinge on the round one pick range.

Both guys that have underperformed compared to the lofty expectations placed on them early on. I think upside wise they have the same ceiling. But I think Alshon's woes are partly because he's fat and lazy. As an Eagles fan I hope I'm wrong, but I'm just not a Jeffrey fan. I have no animosity towards Moncrief though, lol. If I could get a 2018 1st on top of him for Alshon, I'd have already sold him.

Alshon if you want to win now

If you want to win now. Alshon. If rebuilding the other side. If you think the 1st will be top 7 id prob lean the pick and moncreif

Favrezilla wrote: ↑Sun Aug 20, 2017 8:41 am Alshon any day or format. Even with a first unless it's guaranteed top3-4

I also really dislike moncreif .

This

Alshon is the only one that's proven to be elite rather than just hoped to be

Goddard wrote: ↑Sun Aug 20, 2017 12:24 pm

Favrezilla wrote: ↑Sun Aug 20, 2017 8:41 am Alshon any day or format. Even with a first unless it's guaranteed top3-4

I also really dislike moncreif .

This

same with me...i am going to try to trade him in my league as soon as he has a good game