Pryor or Diggs

[Walter Sobchak]

Who do you have rated higher and what would you expect to recieve for them pick wise

[jpusmc0311]

As much as I like Pryor, I'd have to go with Diggs here... I think Diggs is worth 1.3-1.6 in draft picks.

[MarkimusPrime]

Personally, I like Diggs more. I have Diggs so maybe I am biased. Great hands, great separation ability. Showed a good connection with Teddy (who should be back next year) but he seems to always have an injury or too that keeps his ceiling grounded. Though it could be Bradford that is holding him down also. I would say mid-late 1st. Early to Mid 2nd for Pryor.

[dipANDglide]

Diggs easily. He's 4(?) years younger and has more developed WR skills then Pryor.

[moishetreats]

Diggs easily. He's 4(?) years younger and has more developed WR skills then Pryor.

x2

[smmcfarl]

Diggs for me as well.

[BuckeyeNation]

Like both players, but I'd take Diggs by a fair amount. Injuries are what sunk Diggs' value coming out of college so it's possible that the lingering injuries he's dealt with this season will be the norm for him going forward. That said, I think Diggs being banged up presents a bit of a buy-low on him and it's the reason why he's looking at a 900-1000 yard season this year as opposed to a 1300-1400 yard season.

[Coogan Football]

Diggs easily. He's 4(?) years younger and has more developed WR skills then Pryor.

x5, not even close IMO


Pryor + mid/late 1st = Diggs

[hockeyBjj]

Diggs is by far better. I would be hesitant at all to trade him even for a first. He's still young a developing and is already showing WR1 numbers in ppr leagues, with him only going up. He's what you'd typically be happy for a first to turn into. Hopefully MN improves their O-line as when they can give their QBs time, both Bradford and Teddy look to him first. If he happens to get traded at some point in his career, his value would most likely go up again.

[Space Cowboy]

I'd say Diggs with the gap being a late rd 1 or early rd 2 if you really like Pryor.

[flyersfan1981]

Interesting debate!

I only look at things in 3-year windows and I have to be honest, I am very impressed with Pryor. Pryor is big, fast, and appears to have pretty good hands and transitioned well to the WR position. I am guessing he leaves Cleveland and I think the ceiling for the next 3 years is higher with Pryor. If he were the #2 to an established #1, he could dominate. Diggs has been great, but he has his flaws also. Now to be fair, most of them are where he plays as Minny just can't solve their QB problem and their stale offense in general.

If I were buying and the cost was the same I would narrowly choose Diggs, but if I were looking to buy one, I would probably buy Pryor at the cheaper price tag because I think he and Diggs can offer similar production for the next 3 years.

[mike40]

I own diggs and prefer him over Pryor. Would expect an offerror of a mid 1st if I were trying to trade him. Don't think he'll fetch a top 3 pick. Like a previous poster said I'll look to buy Pryor if the price is a mid 2nd easily

[ADrunkenCaveman]

Diggs easily. He's 4(?) years younger and has more developed WR skills then Pryor.

x5, not even close IMO


Pryor + mid/late 1st = Diggs

Diggs hands down.

[Draft Master]

Interesting debate!

I only look at things in 3-year windows and I have to be honest, I am very impressed with Pryor. Pryor is big, fast, and appears to have pretty good hands and transitioned well to the WR position. I am guessing he leaves Cleveland and I think the ceiling for the next 3 years is higher with Pryor. If he were the #2 to an established #1, he could dominate. Diggs has been great, but he has his flaws also. Now to be fair, most of them are where he plays as Minny just can't solve their QB problem and their stale offense in general.

If I were buying and the cost was the same I would narrowly choose Diggs, but if I were looking to buy one, I would probably buy Pryor at the cheaper price tag because I think he and Diggs can offer similar production for the next 3 years.

[Sgtpsych]

Diggs definitely. Better talent and would love shares. I just don't want anything in Cleveland until things get fixed.